UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
SCHEDULE 14A
Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. )
Filed by the Registrant ☑
Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ☐
Check the appropriate box:
☑ Preliminary Proxy Statement
☐ Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2))
☐ Definitive Proxy Statement
☐ Definitive Additional Materials
☐ Soliciting Material Pursuant to § 240.14a-12
Chubb Limited
(Name of Registrant as Specified in its Charter)
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if Other Than the Registrant)
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box):
☑ | No fee required. |
☐ | Fee computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11. |
(1) | Title of each class of securities to which transaction applies: |
(2) | Aggregate number of securities to which transaction applies: |
(3) | Per unit price or other underlying value of transaction computed pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (set forth the amount on which the filing fee is calculated and state how it was determined): |
(4) | Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction: |
(5) | Total fee paid: |
☐ | Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. |
☐ | Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. |
(1) | Amount Previously Paid: |
(2) | Form, Schedule or Registration Statement No.: |
(3) | Filing Party: |
(4) | Date Filed: |
![]() |
To my fellow shareholders,
For Chubb, 2016 was an excellent year financially, strategically and operationally. Financially, we produced record annual operating earnings per share, world-class combined ratios, strong book and tangible book value growth, and a good operating return on equity. We accomplished these results despite elevated catastrophe losses and soft property and casualty (P&C) market conditions globally. Operationally, we completed the largest merger in insurance history, and managed a transformational company-wide global integration effort, achieving substantial cost efficiencies ahead of plan. At the same time, we stayed focused on our core business of underwriting and servicing customers and distribution partners, retaining our commercial and personal lines customers at or above all-time highs. We also launched new products and entirely new businesses, made investments in our people, technologies, and capabilities, and began to harness the complementary strengths of the organization through a variety of revenue initiatives. By the end of 2016, we had achieved or exceeded all of the financial and non-financial targets we established when we initiated the merger.
Together, we have built Chubb to be the largest publicly traded P&C insurance company in the world. For all of the change this company has embraced and managed, however, there are fundamental attributes that have been constants: staying focused on our core business of insurance, maintaining underwriting discipline, providing excellent service to our customers and having an execution orientation. These and other elements of our culture define who we are and guide us as we look to the future.
We are also guided by the feedback we receive from our shareholders. In 2016, we engaged with shareholders on a variety of topics as part of our annual shareholder outreach process. A significant focus this year was on our compensation program. While our executive compensation system has served us well, in response to shareholder feedback, and recognizing the companys broader operational and risk management complexity and evolving executive compensation best practices, our Boards Compensation Committee has been evaluating our compensation program. The Committees objective was to help ensure that our executive pay remains linked to the financial performance of our company and the realization of value for our shareholders. A number of changes to our compensation program are described in this proxy statement, including greater transparency around performance evaluation and adjustments to vesting and other provisions of our performance-share equity grants to further link executive compensation to company performance and the long-term interest of shareholders.
Our aim has been to provide you with a proxy statement that clearly presents the information you need for the business that will be conducted at the annual general meeting on May 18.
Your vote is important, and we encourage you to vote your shares. On behalf of the Board, thank you for your support and for believing in Chubb. |
![]() |
Sincerely,
Evan G. Greenberg Chairman and Chief Executive Officer |
Notice of 2017 Annual Meeting of Shareholders
|
2017 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders |
||||||||||
Date and Time | Place | Record Date | Proxy Mailing Date | |||||||
May 18, 2017, 2:45 p.m. | Chubb Limited | March 27, 2017, except as | On or about April 6, 2017 | |||||||
Central European Time | Bärengasse 32 | provided in Who is | ||||||||
CH-8001, Zurich | entitled to vote? in this | |||||||||
Switzerland | proxy statement | |||||||||
Agenda
Notice of Internet availability of proxy materials: Shareholders of record are being mailed, on or around April 6, 2017, a Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials providing instructions on how to access the proxy materials and our Annual Report on the Internet, and if they prefer, how to request paper copies of these materials.
If you plan to attend the meeting, you must request an admission ticket by following the instructions in this proxy statement by May 11, 2017. | ||
By Order of the Board of Directors,
Joseph F. Wayland Executive Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary April , 2017, Zurich, Switzerland |
Your vote is important. Please vote as promptly as possible by following the instructions on your Notice of Internet Availability of Proxy Materials, whether or not you plan to attend the meeting. |
Proxy Summary
2017 Annual General Meeting
Date and Time | Place | Record Date | Mailing Date | |||
May 18, 2017, 2:45 p.m. | Chubb Limited | March 27, 2017, except as | On or about April 6, 2017 | |||
Central European Time | Bärengasse 32 | provided in Who is entitled | ||||
CH-8001, Zurich Switzerland |
to vote? in this proxy statement |
Meeting Agenda and Board Voting Recommendations
Board Vote | Page | |||||||||
Meeting Agenda
|
Recommendation
|
Reference
|
||||||||
1 | Approval of the management report, standalone financial statements and consolidated financial statements of Chubb Limited for the year ended December 31, 2016 | For | 13 | |||||||
2 | Allocation of disposable profit and distribution of a dividend from reserves | |||||||||
2.1 | Allocation of disposable profit | For | 15 | |||||||
2.2 | Distribution of a dividend out of legal reserves (by way of release and allocation to a dividend reserve) | For | 16 | |||||||
3 | Discharge of the Board of Directors | For | 18 | |||||||
4 | Election of Auditors | |||||||||
4.1 | Election of PricewaterhouseCoopers AG (Zurich) as our statutory auditor | For | 19 | |||||||
4.2 | Ratification of appointment of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (United States) as independent registered public accounting firm for purposes of U.S. securities law reporting | For | 19 | |||||||
4.3 | Election of BDO AG (Zurich) as special audit firm | For | 21 | |||||||
5 | Election of the Board of Directors | For each nominee | 22 | |||||||
6 | Election of the Chairman of the Board of Directors | For | 31 | |||||||
7 | Election of the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors |
For each nominee | 33 | |||||||
8 | Election of Homburger AG as independent proxy |
For | 34 | |||||||
9 | Approval of Amended and Restated Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan | For | 35 | |||||||
10 | Approval of maximum compensation of the Board of Directors and Executive Management |
|||||||||
10.1 | Compensation of the Board of Directors until the next annual general meeting |
For | 41 | |||||||
10.2 | Compensation of Executive Management for the next calendar year |
For | 43 | |||||||
11 | Advisory vote on executive compensation (U.S. securities law) |
For | 47 | |||||||
12 | Advisory vote on frequency of submission of the advisory vote on executive compensation (U.S. securities law) | 1 Year | 49 |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 3
Proxy Summary
Director Nominee Information
This table provides summary information about our director nominees, each of whom is currently a member of our Board of Directors. Each of our directors stands for annual election to a one-year term. Accordingly, each director nominee has been nominated to hold office until the next annual general meeting after election. See Agenda Item 5, the election of directors, for additional information on our director nominees.
Chartered Committee Membership | ||||||||||||||||||
Nominee | Age | Director Since |
Principal Occupation | Executive |
Nominating & Governance |
Audit | Compensation | Risk & Finance | ||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | 62 | 2002 | Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Chubb Limited |
Chair
|
||||||||||||||
Robert M. Hernandez Lead Director |
72 | 1985 | Retired Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer, USX Corporation |
l |
l |
l |
||||||||||||
Michael G. Atieh | 63 | 1991 | Retired Chief Financial and Business Officer, Ophthotech Corporation |
l |
|
Chair
|
|
|||||||||||
Sheila P. Burke | 66 | 2016 | Faculty Research Fellow, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University |
l | ||||||||||||||
James I. Cash | 69 | 2016 | Emeritus Professor of Business Administration, Harvard University |
|
l
|
|
||||||||||||
Mary Cirillo |
69 |
2006 |
Retired Executive Vice
President and |
l |
Chair
|
l |
||||||||||||
Michael P. Connors | 61 | 2011 | Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Information Services Group, Inc. |
l |
l |
Chair
|
||||||||||||
John A. Edwardson | 67 | 2014 | Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, CDW Corporation |
l
| ||||||||||||||
Leo F. Mullin | 74 | 2007 | Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Delta Airlines |
l | ||||||||||||||
Kimberly A. Ross | 51 | 2014 | Chief Financial Officer, Baker Hughes Incorporated |
|
l
|
|
||||||||||||
Robert W. Scully
|
67
|
2014
|
Retired Co-President, Morgan Stanley |
l
|
l
|
|||||||||||||
Eugene B. Shanks, Jr. | 70 |
2011 |
Retired President, Bankers Trust Company |
l | ||||||||||||||
Theodore E. Shasta | 66 | 2010 | Retired Partner, Wellington Management Company |
|
l |
|
||||||||||||
David H. Sidwell | 64 | 2014 | Retired Chief Financial Officer, Morgan Stanley |
|
l |
|
||||||||||||
Olivier Steimer |
61 |
2008 |
Chairman, Banque Cantonale Vaudoise |
l
|
Chair
| |||||||||||||
James M. Zimmerman | 73 | 2016 | Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Federated Department Stores, Inc. (Macys) |
l
|
l
|
4 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Proxy Summary
Governance Highlights
Compensation Highlights
Executive Summary
Our Board is proud of Chubbs truly outstanding management team, led by our CEO, Evan Greenberg. As it has for many years, our management team delivered superior performance in 2016 on an absolute and relative basis exceeding our own high financial goals, outperforming peers and delivering substantial value to shareholders. Significantly, these results came as the management team was transforming the Company through the integration of ACE Limited (ACE) and The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp.) into the largest publicly-traded property and casualty insurance company in the world, with operations in 54 countries and a market value of more than $60 billion.
The Boards compensation recommendations for 2016 reflect both this success and the Companys philosophy to closely link compensation to performance, ensuring that our leadership team remains highly motivated, and strongly aligning remuneration outcomes with the creation of shareholder value. The success of this philosophy is demonstrated not only in this years results, but in consistently high financial, operating and stock price performance over time. Over the past decade, under Evan Greenbergs leadership, the Company has had outstanding growth in tangible book value per share, an industry-leading combined ratio and top-quartile Total Shareholder Return (TSR).
While our compensation system has served us well, we made significant enhancements this year reflecting best practice and our extensive shareholder outreach. We listened to our shareholders and incorporated their feedback to make our pay-for-performance and shareholder alignment even stronger.
What We Heard |
What We Did | |||
Performance share earning period should be longer-term, with cliff-vesting |
|
Moved to 3-year cliff-vesting, eliminated 4-year | ||
Eliminate second chance look-back for performance shares |
|
Eliminated look-back in new performance awards for 2017 and going forward | ||
Consider using multiple metrics (including TSR) for performance share vesting |
|
Added P&C combined ratio to tangible book value per share as new performance share metric | ||
Added TSR modifier for premium performance share awards | ||||
Premium share target (200%) seems too high |
|
Reduced maximum target to 165% | ||
Additional detail on CEO pay decision would be helpful |
|
Included more specifics regarding link between performance and CEO pay |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 5
Proxy Summary
Our CEO Compensation Process
Our CEO, Evan Greenberg, has led the Company to extraordinary success over his 13-year tenure. That success continued in 2016 with exceptional financial and strategic results. His compensation reflects that success.
Each year, the Compensation Committee sets a scorecard for the potential range of CEO compensation, with top-, middle- and low-end bands tied to achievement of specific financial, operational and strategic goals, considered together with TSR, as reflected in the following summary for 2016:
* | Includes $4 million special one-time grant of performance shares in recognition of substantial additional work associated with the pre-closing phase of the Chubb Corp. acquisition. The grant was part of our Compensation Committees final compensation awards applicable to 2015; however, in accordance with SEC rules, this one-time grant is included in certain 2016 compensation tables that follow because the grant date was in February 2016. |
6 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Proxy Summary
Why Vote For Say-on-Pay?
Our Board recommends that you vote For the approval of our Swiss say-on-pay and non-binding SEC say-on-pay proposals. In support of these recommendations, we highlight the following key factors:
Strong financial performance both in absolute terms and relative to our peers, including:
Outstanding strategic and tactical success in creating the worlds largest publicly traded P&C insurance company through the merger of ACE and Chubb Corp., with integration savings and synergies realized ahead of schedule and above initial projections, including:
We listened to our shareholders and made changes to our executive compensation program for 2017 to ensure a continued strong link between pay and performance and increased transparency (see page 5 for details on the changes).
* | 2016 As If results include the combined companys results for the first 14 days of January and exclude any impact from purchase accounting adjustments related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition. 2015 As If results include legacy ACE plus legacy Chubb historical results. We acquired Chubb Corp. on January 14, 2016. |
How Our Compensation Program Works
What We Reward
Superior operating and financial performance, as measured against our peers, prior year and Board-approved plan
Achievement of strategic goals
Superior underwriting and risk management in all our business activities |
|
How We Link Pay to Performance
Core link: Performance measured across 4 key metrics, against peers, prior year and Board- approved plan Tangible book value per share growth Operating return on equity Operating income P&C combined ratio
TSR modifier in addition to metrics and strategic scorecard
Consideration of strategic achievements, including execution of key non-financial objectives |
|
How We Paid
$19.8 million CEO reported pay
Down vs. 2015, inclusive of one-time $4 million performance share grant determined in February 2016 in connection with Chubb Corp. acquisition pre-closing and integration planning
Other NEO reported pay
Down vs. 2015, inclusive of one-time performance share grants determined in February 2016 in connection with Chubb Corp. acquisition pre-closing and integration planning
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 7
Proxy Summary
Compensation Profile
Approximately 93 percent of our CEOs and 86 percent of our other NEOs total direct compensation is variable or at-risk.*
* | Excluding the special one-time long-term incentive equity awards granted to the CEO and the other NEOs in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition. |
How We Use Peer Groups
We utilize two peer groups in order to (1) assess our financial performance against key metrics relative to our P&C insurance industry peers (Financial Performance Peer Group) and (2) align our compensation with U.S. companies of comparable size and complexity that we seek to be competitive with for talent and compensation purposes (Compensation Benchmarking Peer Group).
Financial Performance Peer Group |
Compensation Benchmarking Peer Group | |||||
American International Group, Inc.
CNA Financial Corporation
The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc.
The Travelers Companies, Inc.
XL Group plc
Zurich Financial Services Group |
The Allstate Corporation
American Express Company
American International Group, Inc.
Aon plc
Bank of America Corporation
The Bank of New York Mellon
BlackRock, Inc.
Cigna Corp.
|
Citigroup Inc.
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc.
MetLife, Inc.
Morgan Stanley
Prudential Financial, Inc.
The Travelers Companies, Inc. |
8 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Proxy Summary
Long-Term Performance Highlights
Chubb has a distinguished, long-term track record of performance and outperformance relative to its insurance industry peers. The following charts reflect our performance across key financial and operating measures starting in 2004 when Evan Greenberg became CEO of the Company.
Operating Income |
Operating ROE | |
2004-2016 Operating Income against Financial Performance Peer Group average (indexed to Chubb 2004 operating income)* | 2004-2016 Operating ROE against Financial Performance Peer Group average | |
![]() |
![]() | |
* Chubb operating income grew from $1 billion in 2004 to $4.7 billion in 2016 (377%). Average peer generated only $553 million of operating income in 2016 for every $1 billion of operating income in 2004 (-45%). Zurich is presented with net income because it does not use operating income as a financial measure. |
||
Total Shareholder Return |
P&C Combined Ratio | |
2004-2016 TSR against Financial Performance Peer Group average* | 2004-2016 P&C CR against Financial Performance Peer Group average | |
![]() |
![]() | |
* An investment in one Chubb share on January 1, 2004 ($41.15) was worth $174.05 at December 31, 2016 (including dividend reinvestment), versus $105.59 for the same amount invested in the average share of our peers.
|
Source: SNL and company disclosures
Book Value per Share & Tangible Book Value per Share
2004-2016 BVPS and TBVPS
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 9
Proxy Summary
2016 Performance: Key Metrics
The Compensation Committee evaluates our performance across the following key metrics relative to our Financial Performance Peer Group, Board-approved plan and prior year.
Our average relative performance across the metrics described below exceeded the 90th percentile of our Financial Performance Peer Group.
Book value per share growth & Tangible book value per share growth |
15.4% | Book value per share growth exceeded plan and prior year | ||
-16.1% | The decrease in tangible book value per share growth is reflective of the expected 29.3% dilution at the closing of the Chubb Corp. acquisition. Tangible book value per share grew 13.2 points from the closing through the end of 2016 and exceeded plan. Adjusted for the Chubb Corp. acquisition, tangible book value per share growth was in the 100th percentile and exceeded each member of our Financial Performance Peer Group | |||
Operating return on equity |
10.5% | Relative performance was above the 80th percentile of our Financial Performance Peer Group. Absolute performance exceeded plan but was down compared to 11.5% in 2015 | ||
Operating income |
$4.7B | Relative performance was in the upper quartile of our Financial Performance Peer Group. Absolute performance exceeded plan, and exceeded prior year by 47% | ||
P&C combined ratio |
88.7% |
Relative performance was in the 100th percentile and exceeded each member of our Financial Performance Peer Group, as well as plan. P&C combined ratio increased compared to 87.4% (87.5% on an As If basis) in 2015 | ||
Total Shareholder Return |
16% 1-year 11% 3-year |
Relative to our Financial Performance Peer Group, 1-year TSR was in the 73rd percentile and 3-year TSR was in the 76th percentile. Both 1-year TSR and 3-year TSR exceeded plan and prior year |
2016 Strategic Achievements
Chubb continued to invest in the future of the Company consistent with our strategic goals:
| Completed the largest merger in insurance history through our acquisition of Chubb Corp., creating the worlds largest publicly traded P&C insurance company |
| Executed on a transformational company-wide global integration effort; integration savings ($325 million in 2016) and synergies realized ($800 million by end of 2018) ahead of schedule and above initial projections |
| Launched new commercial specialty product division while maintaining excellence in our core business of underwriting and servicing customers and distribution partners, retaining our commercial and personal lines customers at or above all-time highs |
| Continued to expand analytics and use of predictive modeling to support underwriting, marketing, sales and claims |
Payfor-Performance Framework
Each NEO has an annual cash incentive and long-term incentive opportunity.
Annual Cash Incentive | Long-Term/Equity Incentive | |||
CEO |
05X base salary |
09X base salary | ||
Other NEOs |
03X base salary |
05X base salary |
To fall in the upper end of the ranges described above, relative Company performance must fall in the upper quartile of the Financial Performance Peer Group and absolute performance must exceed plan and prior year. The above ranges may be exceeded in the judgment of the Compensation Committee if relative Company performance substantially exceeds the Financial Performance Peer Group and absolute performance substantially exceeds plan and prior year.
10 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Proxy Summary
2016 Compensation Decisions
Using our pay-for-performance framework, and recognizing both the outstanding 2016 results as measured by the key metrics, as well as the Companys strategic achievements, including the integration of ACE and Chubb entities into the worlds largest publicly-traded P&C company, the Compensation Committee determined to award cash bonuses and equity awards at the top end of the pay-for-performance framework. Specifically, our Compensation Committee awarded an annual cash bonus to our CEO at 4.7X base salary and to our other NEOs at 1.9X to 2.9X base salary, and granted long-term incentive equity awards to our CEO at 8.4X base salary and our other NEOs at 2.9X to 4.9X base salary.
2016 Summary Compensation Table
The below table sets forth 2016 compensation for our NEOs as calculated in accordance with applicable SEC regulations. Additional detail can be found in the Executive Compensation section of this proxy statement.
Name and Principal Position | Annual Base Salary |
Annual Cash Bonus |
Stock Awards* |
Option Awards |
Change in Pension Value and Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Earnings |
All Other Compensation |
Total | |||||||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | $1,400,000 | $6,600,000 | $12,850,051 | $2,406,837 | | $1,162,598 | $24,419,486 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft | $768,750 | $1,470,000 | $2,818,747 | $494,616 | | $620,577 | $6,172,690 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Chief Financial Officer | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh | $896,111 | $2,610,000 | $5,174,945 | $836,266 | | $453,691 | $9,971,013 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Executive Vice Chairman and Chief Operating Officer |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump | $840,000 | $1,760,000 | $999,946 | | $2,288,521 | $152,178 | $6,040,645 | |||||||||||||||||||||
President, North America Commercial and Personal Insurance |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica | $793,519 | $1,980,000 | $3,962,632 | $642,511 | | $413,348 | $7,792,010 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Vice Chairman; President, North America Major Accounts and Specialty Insurance |
* | In accordance with SEC rules, includes special one-time performance share grant determined in February 2016 in recognition of extraordinary efforts in connection with the substantial additional work associated with the pre-closing phase of the Chubb Corp. acquisition, which was announced on July 1, 2015 and completed on January 14, 2016. The awards were granted as follows: $4 million for Mr. Greenberg, $1 million for Mr. Bancroft, $2.1 million for Mr. Keogh, $1 million for Mr. Krump and $1.6 million for Mr. Lupica. These awards are expected to be of a one-time nature and will not be considered for the purpose of determining future compensation. |
Executive Compensation, Good Governance and Risk Management
Our executive compensation program and practices are consistent with our strong culture of good corporate governance and effective enterprise risk management. Our compensation practices take into account risk management and, through significant at-risk pay and other means, broadly align total compensation with the medium- and long-term financial results of the Company.
The key objectives of our executive compensation program are to: |
Emphasize long-term performance and value creation that, while not immune to short-term financial results, encourages sensible risk-taking in pursuit of superior long-term operating performance.
Assure that executives do not take imprudent risks to achieve compensation goals.
Provide, to the extent practicable, that executives are not rewarded with short-term compensation for risk-taking actions that may not manifest in outcomes until after the compensation is paid. |
Sound corporate governance through the institution or prohibition of certain policies and practices, as well as our Compensation Committees continuous oversight of our compensation programs design and effectiveness, ensure that these key objectives are fulfilled.
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 11
Proxy Summary
Our corporate governance helps us mitigate and manage risks we face as an organization by providing a framework that guides how management runs the business and how our Board provides oversight. This is especially pertinent as it applies to our executive compensation program, and our Compensation Committee has taken steps to ensure that our program aligns with our corporate values and culture by adopting policies that discourage excessive risk-taking, ensure a stake in long-term company performance and hold executives accountable for individual and company performance.
What We Do
|
What We Dont Do
| |||||
Substantial equity component to align pay with performance
Significant amount of at-risk pay (93% for CEO, 86% for other NEOs)
Significant mandatory share ownership requirements (CEO 7X base salary; other NEOs 4X base salary)
Independent compensation consultant at every Compensation Committee meeting
Double trigger change in control payout
Detailed individual performance criteria
Clawback of unvested equity in certain circumstances
Peer groups reevaluated annually
Employment agreements with non-competition and non-solicitation terms for Executive Management
|
No hedging of Chubb securities
No repricing or exchange of underwater stock options
No options backdating
No special tax gross ups
No excessive perquisites for executives
No multi-year guaranteed bonuses
No disproportionate supplemental pensions |
In developing and maintaining a compensation program that appropriately rewards pay for performance and drives shareholder value, our Compensation Committee periodically:
| Reviews the components of total compensation and the appropriate level of compensation that should be variable or at-risk (for additional information on the components of total compensation, see Compensation Profile above). |
| Analyzes our long-term equity awards so that vesting periods and terms are aligned with long-term shareholder interests. |
| Re-evaluates the composition of our Compensation Benchmarking and Financial Performance Peer Groups. |
Our Compensation Committee works closely with our independent compensation consultant to analyze market data, review peer groups, evaluate trends in best practices and assist the Compensation Committee in determining the appropriate amount and forms of compensation paid to our executives.
The Compensation Committee may make changes to our compensation program based on its independent judgment, including upon the consideration of best practices and shareholder feedback. For example, the Compensation Committee approved significant revisions to the vesting and other parameters of our performance share plan for grants beginning in 2017.
12 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Approval of the Management Report, Standalone Financial
Statements and Consolidated Financial Statements of Chubb Limited
for the year ended December 31, 2016
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to approve Chubb Limiteds management report, standalone financial statements and consolidated financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2016.
Explanation
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 13
Agenda Item 1
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
|
Our Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR approval of the Companys
management
|
14 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Allocation of Disposable Profit and Distribution of a Dividend out of
Legal Reserves (by Way of Release and Allocation to a Dividend Reserve)
2.1 Allocation of disposable profit
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 15
Agenda Item 2
2.2. Distribution of a dividend out of legal reserves (by way of release and allocation to a dividend reserve)
16 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 2
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 17
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to discharge the Board of Directors for the financial year ended December 31, 2016.
Explanation
As is customary for Swiss corporations and in accordance with Article 698, para. 2, no. 5 of the Swiss Code of Obligations as well as Article 9, no. 4 of our Articles of Association, shareholders are requested to discharge the members of the Board of Directors from liability for their activities during the year ended December 31, 2016. This discharge is not for liability relating to facts that have not been disclosed to shareholders. Registered shareholders that do not vote in favor of this agenda item are not bound by the result for a period ending six months after the vote.
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes, blank or invalid ballots or the votes of any member of or nominee to the Companys Board of Directors, any executive officer of the Company or any votes represented by the Company, is required to approve this agenda item.
![]() |
Our Board of
Directors recommends a vote FOR the agenda item to discharge the members of
|
18 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
4.1 Election of PricewaterhouseCoopers AG (Zurich) as our statutory auditor
4.2 Ratification of appointment of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (United States) as independent registered public accounting firm for purposes of U.S. securities law reporting
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 19
Agenda Item 4
20 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 4
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
![]() |
Our Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the ratification of the appointment
of
|
4.3 Election of BDO AG (Zurich) as special audit firm
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 21
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to elect each of the director nominees listed below individually to the Board of Directors until our next annual general meeting.
Explanation
Under the Minder Ordinance and our Articles of Association, our shareholders elect all of our directors annually. Our Board may not appoint directors to fill vacancies.
Our Articles of Association state that the Board of Directors must consist of three to 20 members, the exact number to be determined by shareholders.
For more information about our Board of Directors and current director nominees, please see the Corporate Governance section of this proxy statement.
Our Director Nominating Process |
Director Skills Criteria | |||
Each year the Nominating & Governance Committee reviews the current composition of the Board, including diversity, skills and qualifications. Based on their assessment, the Committee recommends director nominees to the Board. | Directors should have the following skills and attributes:
broad-based business knowledge and contacts,
prominence and sound reputation in their fields,
global business perspective, and
commitment to good corporate citizenship. |
In addition, directors should be able and prepared to provide wise and thoughtful counsel to top management on the full range of potential issues facing the Company. They should represent all shareholders and not any special interest group or constituency. Directors must possess the highest personal and professional integrity and commitment to ethical and moral values. They also must have the time necessary to fully meet their duty of care to the shareholders and be willing to commit to service over the long haul, if called upon. |
Our Director Nominees
Our Board of Directors has nominated a slate of 16 director nominees, each of whom is a currently serving as a director, for election to the Board of Directors. All directors will serve a one year term from the 2017 Annual General Meeting until our next annual general meeting. There will be a separate vote on each nominee.
The current directors who are standing for reelection are Evan G. Greenberg, Robert M. Hernandez, Michael G. Atieh, Sheila P. Burke, James I. Cash, Mary Cirillo, Michael P. Connors, John A. Edwardson, Leo F. Mullin, Kimberly A. Ross, Robert W. Scully, Eugene B. Shanks, Jr., Theodore E. Shasta, David H. Sidwell, Olivier Steimer and James M. Zimmerman.
22 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 5
Biographical information for each of the nominees is included below.
Evan G. Greenberg
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer, Chubb Limited
Age: 62
Years of Service: 15
Committee Memberships: Executive (Chairman) |
Evan G. Greenberg was elected as our Chairman of the Board in May 2007. We appointed Mr. Greenberg as our President and Chief Executive Officer in May 2004 and as our President and Chief Operating Officer in June 2003. In April 2002, Mr. Greenberg was appointed to the position of Chief Executive Officer of ACE Overseas General. Mr. Greenberg joined the Company as Vice Chairman, ACE Limited, and Chief Executive Officer of ACE Tempest Re in November 2001. Prior to joining the Company, Mr. Greenberg was most recently President and Chief Operating Officer of American International Group, which we refer to as AIG, from 1997 until 2000. From 1975 until 1997, Mr. Greenberg held a variety of senior management positions at AIG, including President and Chief Executive Officer of AIU, AIGs foreign general insurance organization. Mr. Greenberg was during the past five years a member of the Board of Directors of The Coca-Cola Company, where he was Chairman of the Audit Committee and a member of the Finance Committee.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Greenberg has a long and distinguished record of leadership and achievement in the insurance industry. He has been our Chief Executive Officer since 2004 and has served in senior management positions in the industry for 40 years. Mr. Greenbergs record of managing large and complex insurance operations and the skills he developed in his various roles suit him for his role as a Director of the Company and Chairman of the Board, in addition to his President and Chief Executive Officer positions. |
Robert M. Hernandez
Retired Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer, USX Corporation
Independent Lead Director
Age: 72
Years of Service: 32
Committee Memberships: Compensation, Nominating & Governance, Executive |
Robert M. Hernandez is currently our Lead Director. Mr. Hernandez served as Vice Chairman, Director and Chief Financial Officer of USX Corporation (energy and steel) from December 1994 to December 2001, as Executive Vice PresidentAccounting & Finance and Chief Financial Officer of USX from November 1991 to November 1994 and as Senior Vice PresidentFinance & Treasurer from October 1990 to October 1991. Mr. Hernandez was President and Chief Operating Officer of the US Diversified Group of USX from May 1989 until October 1990. Mr. Hernandez is Chairman, Board of Trustees, of the BlackRock Open-End Equity and Long Term Bond Funds. He is the Lead Director of Eastman Chemical Company, a former director of TE Connectivity, Ltd. and the former Chairman of the Board of RTI International Metals, Inc.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Hernandez brings a diverse financial and business management background to the Board and its committees. The range of his senior finance and executive positions with USX is valuable to the Board, given his deep and long-tenured involvement with all aspects of managing and leading a large-cap company. His extensive experience as a director provides additional perspective and qualifications for his Lead Director role with Chubb. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 23
Agenda Item 5
Michael G. Atieh
Retired Chief Financial and Business Officer, Ophthotech Corporation
Age: 63
Years of Service: 26
Committee Memberships: Audit (Chair), Executive |
Michael G. Atieh served as Executive Vice President and Chief Financial and Business Officer of Ophthotech Corporation (a biopharmaceutical company) from September 2014 until March 2016. From February 2009 until its acquisition in February 2012, Mr. Atieh was Executive Chairman of Eyetech Inc., a private specialty pharmaceutical company. He served as Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of OSI Pharmaceuticals from June 2005 until December 2008. He also served as a member of the Board of Directors and Chairman of the Audit Committee for OSI Pharmaceuticals from June 2003 to May 2005. Previously, Mr. Atieh served at Dendrite International, Inc. as Group President from January 2002 to February 2004 and as Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer from October 2000 to December 2001. He also served as Vice President of U.S. Human Health, a division of Merck & Co., Inc., from January 1999 to September 2000, as Senior Vice PresidentMerck-Medco Managed Care, L.L.C., an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of Merck, from April 1994 to December 1998, as Vice PresidentPublic Affairs of Merck from January 1994 to April 1994 and as Treasurer of Merck from April 1990 to December 1993.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Atieh brings a wealth of diverse business experience to the Board which he gained as a senior executive in a Fortune 50 company, large and small biotechnology companies and technology and pharmaceutical service companies. His experience in finance includes serving as a chief financial officer, developing and executing financing strategies for large acquisitions, and subsequently leading the integration efforts of newly acquired companies. He was an audit manager at Ernst & Young and has served as chair of the audit committee of another public company, providing additional experience relevant to his service on the Audit Committee. Mr. Atieh also has deep knowledge of sales and operations gained from over a decade of experience in these disciplines, with extensive customer-facing responsibilities. |
Sheila P. Burke
Faculty Research Fellow, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University
Age: 66
Years of Service: 2
Committee Memberships: Risk & Finance |
Sheila Burke is a Faculty Research Fellow at the Malcolm Wiener Center for Social Policy, and has been a Member of Faculty at the John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, since 2007. She has been a Senior Public Policy Advisor at Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz since 2009. From 1997 to 2016, Ms. Burke was a member of the board of directors of Chubb Corp. and served as chair of its Corporate Governance & Nominating Committee and as a member of the Chubb Corp. boards Executive Committee and Organization & Compensation Committee at the time of the closing of the merger with the Company. From 2004 to 2007, Ms. Burke served as Deputy Secretary and Chief Operating Officer of the Smithsonian Institution. Ms. Burke previously was Under Secretary for American Museums and National Programs, Smithsonian Institution, from June 2000 to December 2003. She was Executive Dean and Lecturer in Public Policy of the John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, from November 1996 until June 2000. Ms. Burke served as Chief of Staff to the Majority Leader of the U.S. Senate from 1985 to 1996. Ms. Burke was, within the last five years, a member of the board of directors of WellPoint, Inc. (now Anthem Inc.).
Skills and Qualifications: Ms. Burke brings an extensive knowledge of public policy matters and governmental affairs, in both public service and private practice, as well as significant experience in outside board service to our Board of Directors. In addition, Ms. Burkes familiarity with Chubb Corp. as a result of her years of service on the Chubb Corp. board is valuable to the oversight of the combined company. |
24 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 5
James I. Cash
Emeritus Professor of Business Administration, Harvard University
Age: 69
Years of Service: 2
Committee Memberships: Audit |
James I. Cash is the emeritus James E. Robison Professor of Business Administration, Harvard University, and was a member of the Harvard Business School faculty from July 1976 to October 2003. He also currently serves on the board of directors of Wal-Mart and was during the past five years a director of General Electric. He currently owns a private company, The Cash Catalyst, LLC, and serves as a special advisor or director of several private companies. From 1996 to 2016, Dr. Cash was a member of the board of directors of Chubb Corp. and served as a member of its Corporate Governance & Nominating Committee and Organization and Compensation Committee at the time of the closing of the merger with the Company.
Skills and Qualifications: Dr. Cash brings an extensive knowledge of information technology, including cyber security, strategic planning and international business operations, and has significant outside board service and business experience. In addition, Dr. Cashs familiarity with Chubb Corp. as a result of his years of service on the Chubb Corp. board is valuable to the oversight of the combined company. |
Mary Cirillo
Retired Executive Vice President and Managing Director, Deutsche Bank
Age: 69
Years of Service: 11
Committee Memberships: Nominating & Governance (Chair), Compensation, Executive |
Mary Cirillo is an advisor to Hudson Venture Partners L.P. (venture capital). She served as Chairman of OPCENTER, LLC (help desk and network operations services) from 2000 to 2004. She was Chief Executive Officer of Global Institutional Services of Deutsche Bank from July 1999 until February 2000. Previously, she served as Executive Vice President and Managing Director of Bankers Trust Company (which was acquired by Deutsche Bank), which she joined in 1997. From 1977 to 1997, she was with Citibank, N.A., most recently serving as Senior Vice President. Ms. Cirillo currently serves as a director of Thomson Reuters Corporation, and within the past five years was a director of DealerTrack Technologies.
Skills and Qualifications: Ms. Cirillo has spent a career in both software product development and management and in commercial banking. She has developed and led global businesses and served as chief executive officer for various subsidiaries at two major financial institutions. She has also led major turnaround efforts in global financial institutions. Ms. Cirillo also has experience in private equity. This business experience allows Ms. Cirillo to bring financial services and technology leadership skills to the Board. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 25
Agenda Item 5
Michael P. Connors
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Information Services Group, Inc.
Age: 61
Years of Service: 6
Committee Memberships: Compensation (Chair), Nominating & Governance, Executive |
Michael P. Connors is Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer of Information Services Group, Inc., a technology insights, market intelligence and advisory services company. He is also a founder of that company. Mr. Connors served as a member of the Executive Board of VNU N.V., a worldwide media and marketing information company, from the merger of ACNielsen into VNU in 2001 until 2005, and he served as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of VNU Media Measurement & Information Group and Chairman of VNU World Directories until 2005. He previously was Vice Chairman of the Board of ACNielsen from its spin-off from the Dun & Bradstreet Corporation in 1996 until 2001, was Senior Vice President of American Express Travel Related Services from 1989 until 1995, and before that was a Corporate Vice President of Sprint Corporation. Mr. Connors is currently a director of Eastman Chemical Company.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Connors is a successful chief executive officer, who brings to the Board substantial corporate management experience in a variety of industries as well as expertise in marketing, media and public relations through his high-level positions at marketing and information-based companies. Mr. Connors skills are enhanced through his current and past experience serving on several public company boards, which furthers his ability to provide valued oversight and guidance to the Company and strategies to inform the Boards general decision-making, particularly with respect to management development, executive compensation and other human resources issues. He has served as the chair of two compensation committees. Though Mr. Connors is the current chief executive officer of a public company, he has attended 100 percent of all Board and committee meetings for which he was a member since joining the Board in 2011. |
John A. Edwardson
Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, CDW Corporation
Age: 67
Years of Service: 3
Committee Memberships: Risk & Finance |
John A. Edwardson is the former Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of CDW Corporation (a technology products and services provider), serving as Chief Executive Officer from 2001 to September 2011 and as Chairman from 2001 to December 2012. Prior to joining CDW, he served as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Burns International Services Corporation, a provider of security services, from 1999 to 2000. He was also President (1994-1998) and Chief Operating Officer (1995-1998) of UAL Corporation (the parent company of United Air Lines, Inc.). Mr. Edwardson is currently a director of Rockwell Collins, Inc. and FedEx Corporation.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Edwardson has extensive management, leadership and international experience. As the former Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of a technology company, he also has significant technological expertise. Mr. Edwardson has additional prior experience serving on a compensation committee, developing insight into executive compensation issues. He also serves as the chair of FedExs audit committee. All of these factors contribute to his value as a Board member. |
26 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 5
Leo F. Mullin
Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Delta Airlines
Age: 74
Years of Service: 10
Committee Memberships: Risk & Finance |
Leo F. Mullin served as Chief Executive Officer of Delta Air Lines, Inc. from 1997 to 2003 and as Chairman of Delta from 1999 to 2004. Mr. Mullin served as a Senior Advisor, on a part-time basis, to Goldman Sachs Capital Partners, a private equity fund group, from 2004 to 2015. He is currently the Chairman of the Board of Directors of Transunion Holding Company and was, within the last five years, a director of Johnson & Johnson and of Education Management Corporation. Mr. Mullin was Vice Chairman of Unicom Corporation and its principal subsidiary, Commonwealth Edison Company, from 1995 to 1997. He was an executive of First Chicago Corporation (bank holding company) from 1981 to 1995, serving as that companys President and Chief Operating Officer from 1993 to 1995.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Mullin served as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of one of the nations largest airlines, giving him exposure to a broad array of complex business, regulatory and international issues. In addition, his long and distinguished career in the banking industry provides additional background and experience with organizational and operational management, global business and financial matters. |
Kimberly A. Ross
Chief Financial Officer, Baker Hughes Incorporated
Age: 51
Years of Service: 3
Committee Memberships: Audit |
Kimberly A. Ross is Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Baker Hughes Incorporated (supplier to the oil and gas industry). She was Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Avon Products Incorporated (a global consumer products company) from November 2011 until September 2014. Prior to joining Avon, Ms. Ross served as the Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Royal Ahold N.V., a food retail company, from 2007 to 2011. Prior to that, Ms. Ross held a variety of senior management positions at Ahold. Ms. Ross was also, during the last five years, a director of Avon.
Skills and Qualifications: Having served as Chief Financial Officer at three companies and as the chair of the audit committee of a private company, Ms. Ross has extensive understanding of finance and financial reporting and internal auditing processes relevant to her service on the Audit Committee. Her work across a spectrum of industries has given Ms. Ross significant management and leadership skills and perspectives that in particular make her an asset to the Board. The Board also benefits from her international executive experience developed through executive positions with multiple companies. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 27
Agenda Item 5
Robert W. Scully
Retired Co-President, Morgan Stanley
Age: 67
Years of Service: 3
Committee Memberships: Compensation, Nominating & Governance |
Robert W. Scully was a member of the Office of the Chairman of Morgan Stanley from 2007 until his retirement in 2009, and he previously served at Morgan Stanley as Co-president, Chairman of global capital markets and Vice Chairman of investment banking.
Prior to joining Morgan Stanley in 1996, he served as a managing director at Lehman Brothers and at Salomon Brothers Inc. Mr. Scully is currently a director of KKR & Co. L.P., UBS AG and Zoetis Inc. and was, during the last five years, a director of Bank of America Corporation and a Public Governor of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA).
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Scullys lengthy career in the global financial services industry brings expertise in capital markets activities and, of particular note, risk management to the Board. Mr. Scully has a broad range of experience with oversight stemming from his extensive service as a director; he has served or is serving on four organizations audit committees (including FINRA), three companies compensation committees, a risk committee and a nominating and governance committee. Mr. Scullys experience with and knowledge of talent development and strategic initiatives are also important to the Board. |
Eugene B. Shanks, Jr.
Retired President, Bankers Trust Company
Age: 70
Years of Service: 6
Committee Memberships: Risk & Finance |
Eugene B. Shanks, Jr. is a member of the Board of Directors of Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac), and chairs its nominating and governance committee as well as serving on its business and risk committee and its executive committee. From 1997 until its sale in 2002, Mr. Shanks was President and Chief Executive Officer of NetRisk, Inc., a risk management software and advisory services company he founded. From 1973 to 1978 and from 1980 to 1995, Mr. Shanks held a variety of positions with Bankers Trust New York Corporation and Bankers Trust Company, including head of Global Markets from 1986 to 1992 and President and Director from 1992 to 1995.
Skills and Qualifications: With two decades of varied banking experience, Mr. Shanks brings extensive finance expertise to the Board. He earned a PhD in economics at Stanford University. In addition he has a strong background in both asset and risk management, which are two areas that are very important to Chubbs business. Our Board also benefits from the leadership experience that Mr. Shanks gained from serving as a president of Bankers Trust. Mr. Shankss public company board experience also contributes to his value as a director. |
Theodore E. Shasta
Retired Partner, Wellington Management Company
Age: 66
Years of Service: 7
Committee Memberships: Audit |
Theodore E. Shasta is a Director of MBIA, Inc. and also serves as the Chair of its Audit Committee and a member of its Finance & Risk Committee. Mr. Shasta was formerly a Senior Vice President and Partner of Wellington Management Company, a global investment advisor. Mr. Shasta joined Wellington Management Company in 1996 and specialized in the financial analysis of publicly-traded insurance companies and retired in June 2009. Prior to joining Wellington Management Company, Mr. Shasta was a Senior Vice President of Loomis, Sayles & Company (investment management). Before that, he served in various capacities with Dewey Square Investors and Bank of Boston. In total, Mr. Shasta spent 25 years covering the insurance industry as a financial analyst.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Shastas history of working in the financial services industry, as well as in the property and casualty insurance arena, brings valuable insight and perspective to the Board. His years of analysis of companies like Chubb and its peer group provide him with deep knowledge of particular business and financial issues we face. His financial acumen and industry knowledge make him a valuable contributor to the Audit Committee. Mr. Shasta has been a Chartered Financial Analyst since 1986. |
28 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 5
David H. Sidwell
Retired Chief Financial Officer,
Age: 64
Years of Service: 3
Committee Memberships: Audit |
David H. Sidwell was Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Morgan Stanley from March 2004 to October 2007, when he retired. From 1984 to March 2004, Mr. Sidwell worked for JPMorgan Chase & Co. in a variety of financial and operating positions, most recently as Chief Financial Officer of JPMorgan Chases investment bank from January 2000 to March 2004. Prior to joining JP Morgan in 1984, Mr. Sidwell was with Price Waterhouse LLP, a major public accounting firm, from 1975 to 1984, where he was qualified as a chartered accountant with the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
Mr. Sidwell is currently Senior Independent Director of UBS AG and was a director of the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) until October 1, 2016. Mr. Sidwell served as a Trustee of the International Accounting Standards Committee Foundation from January 2007 until his term ended in December 2012.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Sidwell has a strong background in accounting, finance and capital markets, as well as the regulation of financial institutions, complementary to his role on the Audit Committee. He also has considerable expertise in risk management from chairing the risk committee of a public company and his executive positions. Mr. Sidwell further contributes experience in executive compensation and corporate governance from his service on the committees of other public company boards. This comprehensive range of experience contributes greatly to his value as a Board member. |
Olivier Steimer
Chairman, Banque Cantonale Vaudoise
Age: 61
Years of Service: 9
Committee Memberships: Risk & Finance (Chair), Executive |
Olivier Steimer is Chairman of the Board of Banque Cantonale Vaudoise. Previously, he worked for the Credit Suisse Group from 1983 to 2002, with his most recent position at that organization being Chief Executive Officer, Private Banking International and member of the Group Executive Board. Mr. Steimer has served since 2013 on the Board of Allreal Holding AG (Swiss real estate manager and developer). He is Chairman of the foundation board of the Swiss Finance Institute. From 2010 to 2014, he was Vice Chairman of the Board of Directors of SBB CFF FFS (the Swiss national railway company), and from 2009 until 2012, he was the Chairman of the Board of Piguet Galland & Cie SA. Since 2009, he has been a member and, since 2012, he has been Vice Chairman of the Bank Council of Swiss National Bank. Mr. Steimer is a Swiss citizen.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Steimer has a strong background of leadership in chairman and chief executive officer roles. He has deep knowledge of sophisticated banking and finance matters derived from his extensive experience in the financial services industry. As a Swiss company, Chubb benefits specifically from Mr. Steimer being a Swiss citizen and resident, and his insight into the Swiss commercial and insurance arenas provides valuable perspective to the Board. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 29
Agenda Item 5
James M. Zimmerman
Retired Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Federated Department Stores, Inc. (Macys)
Age: 73
Years of Service: 2
Committee Memberships: Compensation, Nominating & Governance |
James M. Zimmerman formerly served as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Federated Department Stores, Inc. (Macys). Mr. Zimmerman was Chairman of the Board of Federated from February 2003 until January 2004, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer from May 1997 to February 2003, and President and Chief Operating Officer from March 1988 to May 1997. He began his career with Federated in 1965 after graduating from Rice University in Houston, Texas. Mr. Zimmerman is also currently a member of the board of directors of Fossil, Inc. and within the last five years was a member of the board of directors of Furniture Brands International. From 2008 to 2016, Mr. Zimmerman was a member of the board of directors of Chubb Corp. and served as its Lead Director and as a member of its Executive Committee and Organization & Compensation Committee at the time of the closing of the merger with the Company.
Skills and Qualifications: Mr. Zimmerman brings significant experience to the Board through his roles as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of a major public company and his outside board service and business activities. In addition, Mr. Zimmermans familiarity with Chubb Corp. as a result of his service on the Chubb Corp. board and role as its Lead Director is valuable to the oversight of the combined company. |
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to elect each of the above nominees in this agenda item.
|
The Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the election to the Board of
Directors of each of
|
30 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to elect Evan G. Greenberg as Chairman of the Board of Directors until our next annual general meeting.
Explanation
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 31
Agenda Item 6
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of a majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
|
Our Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the election of Evan G.
Greenberg as the
|
32 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to elect each of the director nominees Michael P. Connors, Mary Cirillo, Robert M. Hernandez, Robert W. Scully and James M. Zimmerman individually as members of the Compensation Committee until our next annual general meeting.
Explanation
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to elect each of the above nominees in this agenda item.
![]() |
The Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR each of the above nominees to
be elected to the
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 33
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to elect Homburger AG as the Companys independent proxy until the conclusion of our next annual general meeting.
Explanation
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of a majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
![]() |
The Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the election of Homburger AG
as
|
34 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to approve the amended and restated Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan (ESPP). The following summary of the ESPP is qualified in its entirety by the complete text of the ESPP contained in Annex A.
Explanation and Purpose
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 35
Agenda Item 9
Eligibility
Participation
36 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 9
Payroll Deductions
Termination of Participation
Purchase of Common Shares
Withholding
All benefits under the ESPP are subject to withholding of all applicable taxes.
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 37
Agenda Item 9
Duration, Amendment and Termination
United States Income Tax Considerations
Tax Advice
U.S. Tax Advice. The preceding discussion is based on U.S. tax laws and regulations presently in effect, which are subject to change, and the discussion does not purport to be a complete description of the U.S. income tax aspects of the ESPP. A participant may also be subject to state and local taxes in connection with the grant of awards under the ESPP. We suggest that participants consult with their individual tax advisors to determine the applicability of the tax rules to the awards granted to them in their personal circumstances.
Non-U.S. Tax Considerations. Participants subject to taxation in other countries should consult their tax advisors.
38 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 9
Common Share Issuances
The following table sets forth shares purchased pursuant to the ESPP for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2016 by the Companys CEO and each of the other Named Executive Officers that participated in the ESPP in 2016 and by the various indicated groups, together with the weighted average purchase price paid per share:
Name | Number of Purchased Shares |
Weighted- average Purchase Price |
||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
| | ||||||
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer |
||||||||
John W. Keogh |
| | ||||||
Executive Vice Chairman and Chief Operating Officer |
||||||||
Phillip V. Bancroft |
| | ||||||
Chief Financial Officer |
||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
189 | $112.30 | ||||||
President, North America Commercial and Personal Insurance |
||||||||
John J. Lupica |
191 | $111.10 | ||||||
Vice Chairman; President, North America Major Accounts and Specialty Insurance |
||||||||
Executive Officer Employee Group (9 persons) |
380 | $111.70 | ||||||
Non-Employee Director Group |
| | ||||||
Non-Executive Officer Employee Group |
218,828 | $111.80 |
New ESPP Benefits
The benefits to be derived under the ESPP by any individual in the future are currently undeterminable. Participation in the ESPP is entirely voluntary and benefits will only be realized by those employees who have chosen to allocate a portion of their Compensation to the purchase of Common Shares of the Company. The total number of shares to be purchased during each Subscription Period cannot be determined in advance, as it will vary based on an individuals elections (which may include an election to terminate participation during a Subscription Period) and the price of a Common Share at the Exercise Date; provided that, in no event may a participant purchase more than $25,000 in value of Common Shares under the ESPP (and any other employee stock purchase plan) in any calendar year.
Authorized Securities under Equity Compensation Plans
The following table presents securities authorized for issuance under equity compensation plans at December 31, 2016:
Plan Category | Number of securities to be issued upon exercise of outstanding options, warrants, and rights |
Weighted-average exercise price of outstanding options, warrants, and rights |
Number of securities remaining available for future issuance under equity compensation plans |
|||||||||
Equity compensation plans approved by security holders(1) |
13,716,372 | $ | 87.29(3) | 21,238,463 | ||||||||
Equity compensation plans not approved by security holders(2) |
49,358 |
(1) | These totals include securities available for future issuance under the following plans: |
i. | Chubb Limited 2016 Long-Term Incentive Plan (LTIP). A total of 19,500,000 shares are authorized to be issued pursuant to awards made as options, stock appreciation rights, stock units, performance shares, performance units, restricted stock, and restricted stock units. The maximum number of shares that may be delivered to participants and their beneficiaries under the LTIP shall be equal to the sum of: (x) 19,500,000 shares of stock; and (y) any shares of stock that have not been delivered pursuant to the ACE LTIP (as defined in clause (ii) of this footnote (1) below) and remain available for grant pursuant to the ACE LTIP, including shares of stock represented by awards granted under the ACE LTIP that are forfeited, expire or are canceled after the Effective Date without delivery of shares of stock or which result in the forfeiture of the shares of stock back to the Company to the extent that such shares would have been added back to the reserve under the terms of the ACE LTIP. As of December 31, 2016, a total of 87 option awards and 1,581 restricted stock unit awards are outstanding, and 20,522,230 shares remain available for future issuance under this plan. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 39
Agenda Item 9
ii. | ACE Limited 2004 Long-Term Incentive Plan (ACE LTIP). As of December 31, 2016, a total of 9,924,502 option awards, 801,192 restricted stock unit awards and 64,761 performance unit awards are outstanding. No additional grants will be made pursuant to the ACE LTIP. |
iii. | The Chubb Corporation Long-Term Incentive Plan (2014) (Chubb Corp. LTIP). As of December 31, 2016, a total of 255,628 option awards, 1,402,670 restricted stock unit awards, 958,250 performance unit awards (representing 100% of the aggregate target in accordance with the Chubb Corp. merger agreement) and 307,701 deferred stock unit awards are outstanding. No additional grants will be made pursuant to the Chubb Corp. LTIP. |
iv. | ESPP. A total of 4,500,000 shares have been authorized for purchase at a discount. As of December 31, 2016, 716,233 shares remain available for future issuance under this plan. |
(2) | These plans are the Chubb Corp. CCAP Excess Benefit Plan (CCAP Excess Benefit Plan) and the Chubb Corp. Deferred Compensation Plan for Directors, under which no Common Shares are available for future issuance other than with respect to outstanding rewards. The CCAP Excess Benefit Plan is a nonqualified, defined contribution plan and covers those participants in the Capital Accumulation Plan of The Chubb Corporation (CCAP) (Chubb Corp.s legacy 401(k) plan) and Chubb Corp.s legacy employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) whose total benefits under those plans are limited by certain provisions of the Internal Revenue Code. A participant in the CCAP Excess Benefit Plan is entitled to a benefit equaling the difference between the participants benefits under the CCAP and the ESOP, without considering the applicable limitations of the Code, and the participants actual benefits under such plans. A participants excess ESOP benefit is expressed as Common Shares. Payments under the CCAP Excess Benefit Plan are generally made: (i) for excess benefits related to the CCAP, in cash annually as soon as practical after the amount of excess benefit can be determined; and (ii) for excess benefits related to the ESOP, in Common Shares as soon as practicable after the participants termination of employment. Allocations under the ESOP ceased in 2004. Accordingly, other than dividends, no new contributions are made to the ESOP or the CCAP Excess Benefit Plan with respect to excess ESOP benefits. |
(3) | Weighted average exercise price excludes shares issuable under performance unit awards and restricted stock unit awards. |
See Note 12 to the consolidated financial statements in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information regarding our equity compensation plans.
What Happens If Shareholders Do Not Approve This Proposal?
In the event of a negative vote on this agenda item by shareholders, the Board of Directors will take the vote of the shareholders into consideration and participants may continue to purchase shares under the ESPP for so long as shares remain available for issuance.
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
The affirmative FOR vote of the majority of the votes cast (in person or proxy) at the Annual General Meeting (such that the number of votes cast in favor of the agenda item exceeds the aggregate of votes cast against the agenda item plus abstentions), not counting broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
|
Our Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the approval of the amended and
restated
|
40 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Approval of the Maximum Compensation of the Board of
Directors and Executive Management
10.1 Compensation of the Board of Directors until the Next
Annual General Meeting
Q&A Relating to Shareholder Ratification of the Maximum Aggregate Compensation
of the Board
For which period does the Board compensation approval apply?
|
The approval applies to compensation for the period from the Annual General Meeting until the end of the next annual general meeting. | |||
What does the maximum aggregate compensation amount include? | The maximum includes a lump sum amount for all potential compensation elements for the period, including:
Annual retainers
Committee chair fees
Equity awards
Attendance fees
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 41
Agenda Item 10
Where can I find more information about director compensation? | For reference, the amounts of compensation paid to directors in 2016 can be found in the Director Compensation section beginning on page 65 of this proxy statement. Under the Minder Ordinance, we also publish an audited annual compensation report, the Swiss Compensation Report, which is included within our Annual Report. These documents are available to shareholders in their proxy materials.
| |||
What process does the Company use to determine the maximum aggregate compensation amount? | Our Board determined the maximum aggregate amount by considering amounts paid under our Outside Directors Compensation Parameters and the size of our Board, by estimating an amount for dividend equivalents paid with respect to certain outstanding deferred restricted stock units (which we stopped granting in 2009) held by some of our longer-serving directors, and by adding a small cushion to permit per-meeting fees to be paid in accordance with our Outside Directors Compensation Parameters in case of additional meetings, should they be necessary.
| |||
Who determines the actual compensation for each individual Board member? | The Board, upon recommendation of the Nominating & Governance Committee, determines the actual individual compensation of each member of the Board, subject to the maximum aggregate compensation amounts ratified by the shareholders.
|
42 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 10
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Items
The affirmative FOR vote of a majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots, is required to approve this agenda item.
|
Our Board of
Directors recommends a vote FOR the approval of the maximum aggregate
|
10.2 Compensation of Executive Management for the Next Calendar Year
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 43
Agenda Item 10
Below are summary answers to certain questions that shareholders may have in connection with this proposal.
Q&A Relating to Shareholder Ratification of the Maximum Aggregate Compensation of
Executive Management
For which period does Executive Management compensation approval apply? | The approval applies to compensation for the next calendar year (2018), including variable compensation that may be paid or granted in the year following the next calendar year based upon satisfaction of performance targets.
| |||||
What does the maximum aggregate compensation amount include? | It includes a lump sum amount for all potential compensation elements for the period, including:
| |||||
Fixed Compensation Base salary |
Variable Compensation including: Cash bonus Long-term equity incentive awards Retirement contributions Additional personal benefits including limited perquisites and provisions for post-employment compensation
| |||||
How is future compensation for 2018 valued for purposes of this requested approval? | The proposed maximum aggregate compensation amount for Executive Management will establish a budget to be used by the Board for Executive Management compensation for 2018. To calculate depletion of this budget and amounts remaining within the shareholder approved amount, cash payments will be valued at the amount actually paid for the various portions of compensation paid in cash; that is, the proposed amount does not factor in a discount to present value.
In accordance with Article 24(e) of our Articles of Association, equity awards will be valued at the fair value on the date of grant, which may be less than the full market value of the shares subject to particular awards. Equity awards may also be either less than or greater than the amount Executive Management ultimately realizes with respect to the awards upon their vesting, exercise or termination. Fair value for awards will be assessed as follows:
stock options: the applicable Black-Scholes value at the date of grant time-based restricted share grants: 100% of the market value of the subject shares as of the date of grant performance share awards: 100% of the market value of the target shares subject to the entire award, inclusive of both the target awards and the premium awards as described elsewhere in this proxy statement.
|
44 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Agenda Item 10
In all cases, amounts actually realized by Executive Management for their equity awards could be less or more than the fair value at time of grant because the stock price for Chubb shares may increase or decrease between the date of grant and the date the shares actually vest, if they vest.
In addition to this potential for share price fluctuation, the fair value of stock options is less than 100% of the value of the shares subject to the options because the options have an exercise price equal to the market value on the date of grant. The fair value of performance shares is less than 100% of the value of the shares subject to the awards on the date of grant because the relevant performance hurdles, for both target awards and performance awards, may not be met. This means that members of Executive Management may realize less than the value of the target awards or no value at all should awards fail to meet performance hurdles. Amounts realized will only exceed the fair value on the date of grant if premium award shares subject to the awards actually vest (in the case of performance share awards) or if the share price on the date of exercise (net of exercise price, in the case of stock options) exceeds the share price at the time of grant.
In the Summary Compensation Table of this proxy statement and in our Swiss Compensation Report contained in the Annual Report, stock options are similarly valued at a Black-Scholes value, and performance shares are reflected at 50% of the value of the entire award (i.e., 100% of the value of the target award). The Summary Compensation Table also includes in a footnote information about the grant date full (potential) value of 2016 performance share awards for NEOs.
| ||||
Who determines the actual compensation for each individual member of Executive Management? | The Board or the Compensation Committee determines the actual individual compensation of each member of Executive Management, subject to the maximum aggregate compensation amounts ratified by the shareholders and other limitations contained in the Articles of Association and the Companys bonus and equity incentive plans. The actual aggregate amount of compensation paid to the individual members of Executive Management may be lower than the maximum aggregate compensation amount for which the Board is seeking ratification. This is because the maximum aggregate compensation amount is calculated based on the assumption that all performance and other measures of applicable bonus and equity-based compensation plans are met or substantially exceeded.
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 45
Agenda Item 10
46 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Advisory Vote to Approve Executive Compensation under U.S. Securities Law Requirements
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to approve, on an advisory basis, the compensation paid to the Companys named executive officers, as disclosed pursuant to the compensation disclosure rules of the SEC for the year ended December 31, 2016, including the Compensation Discussion & Analysis, compensation tables and related material disclosed in this proxy statement. We refer to our named executive officers, who are determined based on relevant compensation and applicable SEC rules, as NEOs.
Explanation
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 47
Agenda Item 11
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
This agenda item is an advisory vote. As such, it is not binding in nature. Therefore, there is no specific approval requirement. However, the Board of Directors will consider that the shareholders have approved executive compensation on an advisory basis if this agenda item receives the affirmative vote of a majority of the votes cast (in person or by proxy) at the Annual General Meeting, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots.
![]()
|
The Board of Directors recommends a vote FOR the approval of our named executive officer compensation.
|
48 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Advisory Vote on the Frequency of the Submission of the Advisory
Vote to Approve Executive Compensation under U.S. Securities
Law Requirements
Agenda Item
Our Board of Directors is asking shareholders to approve, on an advisory basis, how frequently we should seek from shareholders the advisory vote on the compensation paid to the Companys NEOs under U.S. securities law requirements.
Explanation
Voting Requirement to Approve Agenda Item
This agenda item is an advisory vote. As such, it is not binding in nature. Therefore, there is no specific approval requirement. However, the Board of Directors will consider that shareholders have selected, on an advisory basis, whichever frequency receives the highest number of votes cast (in person or by proxy) on this agenda item, not counting abstentions, broker non-votes or blank or invalid ballots.
![]() |
The Board of Directors recommends that the advisory vote on compensation paid to our named executive officers occur annually.
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 49
50 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance Our Corporate Governance Framework
Our Corporate Governance Framework
Board Independence |
The Board has determined that 15 out of 16 of our directors are independent under NYSE regulations and our Categorical Standards for Director Independence.
Our CEO is the only management director.
| |
Board Composition |
Under Swiss law, our shareholders elect directors and determine the number of directors on the Board. Currently, our Articles of Association state there can be between 3 and 20 directors, but these boundaries may be changed by the shareholders.
Our Categorical Standards for Director Independence include director qualification standards and require our Nominating & Governance Committee to annually review Board composition and the skills and attributes of individual Board members, including consideration of diversity factors.
Individuals may not be nominated or re-nominated to the Board after they reach 75 years of age; this prohibition may be waived from time to time as deemed advisable by the Board.
| |
Board Committees |
We have five Board committees Audit, Compensation, Nominating & Governance, Risk & Finance, and Executive.
All committees are composed entirely of independent directors, with the exception of the Executive Committee (our Chairman and CEO serves on the Executive Committee).
| |
Leadership Structure |
Our Chairman is CEO of our company. He interacts closely with our independent Lead Director.
Our Lead Director is appointed by the other independent directors. Among other duties, our Lead Director ensures an appropriate level of Board independence in deliberations and overall governance and chairs executive sessions of the independent directors to discuss certain matters without management present. These executive sessions take place at least every regular Board meeting.
The Lead Director has the ability to call special meetings or schedule executive sessions with the other independent Board members.
| |
Risk Oversight | Our full Board and the Risk & Finance Committee are responsible for risk oversight. Our Board oversees management as it fulfills its responsibilities for the assessment and mitigation of risks and for taking appropriate risks.
| |
Open Communication |
We encourage open communication and strong working relationships among the Lead Director, Chairman and other directors.
Our directors have access to members of management and employees, and our Lead Director and members of our Committees regularly communicate with members of management other than the CEO on a variety of topics.
Shareholders and other interested parties can contact our Board, Audit Committee or Lead Director by email or regular mail.
| |
Accountability to Shareowners |
We elect our directors by majority shareholder voting. There is no plurality concept built into our shareholder voting, unless the number of nominees exceeds the maximum number of director positions as set by shareholders in our Articles of Association. This is because shareholders can determine the number of Board positions and all nominees who receive a majority of votes cast are, by law, elected to the Board.
The Board may not appoint directors to fill vacancies.
Our Chairman, members of the Board of Directors and members of the Compensation Committee are each elected annually.
| |
Succession Planning |
The Board actively monitors our succession planning and management development; they receive regular updates on employee engagement, diversity and retention matters.
Chairman and CEO succession plans under various scenarios are discussed and reviewed annually.
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 51
Corporate Governance Governance Practices and Policies that Guide Our Actions
Governance Practices and Policies that Guide Our Actions
52 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance Governance Practices and Policies that Guide Our Actions
Director Nomination Process and Annual Board Skills Review
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 53
Corporate Governance Director Nomination Process and Annual Board Skills Review
54 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance The Board of Directors
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 55
Corporate Governance Board Leadership Structure
56 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance The Committees of the Board
The Board of Directors has five committees: Audit, Compensation, Nominating & Governance, Risk & Finance and Executive. The principal role, independence standards and meetings held during 2016 are outlined in the following chart. For more information on committee members, see our Board of Director profiles beginning on page 23.
Committee |
Role & Responsibilities | Independence | Meetings Held 2016 | |||
Audit Committee
Chair: Michael G. Atieh
Members: James I. Cash Kimberly A. Ross Theodore E. Shasta David H. Sidwell |
The Audit Committee provides oversight of the integrity of our financial statements and financial reporting process, our compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, our system of internal controls, cyber-security risks, and our audit process.
The Committees oversight includes the performance of our internal auditors and the performance, qualification and independence of our independent registered public accounting firm.
If a member of our Audit Committee simultaneously serves on the audit committees of more than three public companies, the Board is required to determine and disclose whether such simultaneous service would impair the ability of such member to effectively serve on our Audit Committee.
|
All members are independent directors as defined by the NYSE listing standards and applied by the Board; each member meets the financial literacy requirements, per NYSE listing standards
All members are audit committee financial experts as defined under Item 407(d) of Regulation S-K
|
Twelve meetings (eight of which were telephonic) and one in-depth session on important accounting matters
| |||
Compensation Committee
Chair: Michael P. Connors
Members: Mary Cirillo Robert M. Hernandez Robert W. Scully James M. Zimmerman |
The Compensation Committee discharges the Boards responsibilities relating to the compensation of employees. It evaluates the performance of the CEO and other NEOs based on corporate and personal goals and objectives. Based on this evaluation, it sets the CEOs compensation level, both as a committee and together with the other independent directors, and approves NEO compensation.
The Compensation Committee also works with the Nominating & Governance Committee and the CEO on succession planning and periodically consults with the Risk & Finance Committee on matters related to executive compensation and risk.
For more information about how the Compensation Committee determines executive compensation, see the Compensation Discussion & Analysis section of this proxy statement.
|
All members are independent directors, as defined by the NYSE listing standards and applied by the Board | Five meetings and several additional consultations |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 57
Corporate Governance The Committees of the Board
Committee |
Role & Responsibilities | Independence | Meetings Held 2016 | |||
Nominating & Governance
Chair: Mary Cirillo
Members: Michael P. Connors Robert M. Hernandez Robert W. Scully James M. Zimmerman |
The responsibilities of the Nominating & Governance Committee include identification of individuals qualified to become Board members, recommending director nominees to the Board and developing and recommending corporate governance guidelines.
The Committee also has the responsibility to review and make recommendations to the full Board regarding director compensation, examine and approve the Boards committee structure and committee assignments, and advise the Board on matters of organizational and corporate governance.
In addition to general corporate governance matters, the Nominating & Governance Committee approves the Board calendar and assists the Board and the Board committees in their self-evaluations.
|
All members are independent directors, as defined by the NYSE listing standards and applied by the Board | Four meetings | |||
Risk & Finance Committee
Chair: Olivier Steimer
Members: Sheila P. Burke John A. Edwardson Leo F. Mullin Eugene B. Shanks, Jr.
|
Under Swiss law, the Board of Directors has ultimate responsibility for management and direction of the Company. The Risk & Finance Committee helps execute the Boards supervisory responsibilities pertaining to enterprise risk management, capital structure, financing arrangements and investments.
For more information on the Risk & Finance Committees role, see Board Risk Oversight and Risk Management below. |
All members are independent according to our Categorical Standards for Director Independence, as applied by the Board | Four meetings and one training session | |||
Executive Committee
Chair: Evan G. Greenberg
Members: Michael G. Atieh Mary Cirillo Michael P. Connors Robert M. Hernandez Olivier Steimer
|
The Executive Committee may exercise all the powers and authorities of the Board of Directors between meetings of the full Board of Directors, except as expressly limited by applicable law or regulation, stock exchange rule, our Articles of Association or our Organizational Regulations and except for matters expressly reserved for another committee of our Board of Directors. Its primary focus is to act for the full Board when it is not practical to convene meetings of the full Board. | None |
58 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance Board Oversight of Our Independent Advisors
Board Oversight of Our Independent Advisors
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 59
Corporate Governance Board Oversight of Risk and Risk Management
Board Oversight of Risk and Risk Management
What Is Our Related Party Transactions Approval Policy And What Procedures Do We Use To Implement It?
60 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance What Is Our Related Party Transactions Approval Policy And What Procedures Do We Use To Implement It?
What Related Person Transactions Do We Have?
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 61
Corporate Governance What Related Person Transactions Do We Have?
62 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Corporate Governance What Related Person Transactions Do We Have?
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 63
Corporate Governance What Related Person Transactions Do We Have?
Did Our Officers And Directors Comply With Section 16(a) Beneficial Ownership Reporting In 2016?
Executive officers and directors of the Company are subject to the reporting requirements of Section 16 of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934 (the Exchange Act). We believe that all our directors and executive officers complied on a timely basis with filing requirements arising during 2016 under Section 16(a) of the Exchange Act, except that (i) David H. Sidwell filed one late report on Form 4 reporting one Common Shares purchase transaction; (ii) Robert W. Scully filed one late Form 3/A reporting beneficial ownership of Common Shares indirectly held by a trust that were omitted from his Form 3 that had been timely filed; (iii) Paul J. Krump filed two late reports, one late Form 4/A on reporting the granting of two restricted stock awards that should have been included in a prior Form 4 that had been timely filed and one late Form 4 reporting the settlement of deferred stock units upon vesting and the withholding of shares to cover the related tax liability; and (iv) Juan C. Andrade filed one late Form 3/A reporting beneficial ownership of Common Shares that were omitted from his Form 3 that had been timely filed. Each of the filings mentioned in (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv) in the preceding sentence was late as a result of inadvertent administrative error.
64 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Board of Directors Role and Compensation
Elements of Director Compensation
Pay Component
|
2016 Compensation
| |
Standard Compensation Per year of service from May annual general meeting |
$260,000
$160,000 in restricted stock awards based on the fair market value of the Companys Common Shares at the date of award
$100,000 in cash, paid quarterly
| |
Committee Chair Retainers | Audit Committee $25,000
Compensation Committee $20,000
Risk & Finance Committee $15,000
Nominating & Governance Committee $12,000
Paid in quarterly installments
| |
Lead Director Annual Retainer | $50,000
Paid in quarterly installments
| |
Additional Board Meeting Fees | No fees were paid in 2016 for attendance at regular or special Board or Committee meetings.
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 65
Director Compensation Board of Directors Role and Compensation
Director Stock Ownership Requirements
66 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Director Compensation 2016 Director Compensation
2016 Director Compensation
The following table sets forth information concerning director compensation paid or, in the case of restricted stock awards, earned during 2016.
Name | Fees Earned or Paid in Cash |
Stock Awards1 | All Other Compensation2 |
Total | ||||||||||||
Michael G. Atieh |
$78,125 | $206,875 | $108,950 | $393,950 | ||||||||||||
Sheila P. Burke |
$127,500 | $100,000 | $28,032 | $255,532 | ||||||||||||
James I. Cash |
$127,500 | $100,000 | $31,355 | $258,855 | ||||||||||||
Mary Cirillo3 |
| $272,000 | $57,038 | $329,038 | ||||||||||||
Michael P. Connors |
$120,000 | $160,000 | $1,000 | $281,000 | ||||||||||||
John A. Edwardson4 |
| $260,000 | $2,526 | $262,526 | ||||||||||||
Robert M. Hernandez |
$150,000 | $160,000 | $84,498 | $394,498 | ||||||||||||
Lawrence W. Kellner5 |
$140,000 | | $23,609 | $163,609 | ||||||||||||
Peter Menikoff5 |
| $97,500 | $128,431 | $225,931 | ||||||||||||
Leo F. Mullin |
$100,000 | $160,000 | $34,516 | $294,516 | ||||||||||||
Kimberly A. Ross4 |
| $260,000 | $6,850 | $266,850 | ||||||||||||
Robert W. Scully4 |
| $260,000 | $20,000 | $280,000 | ||||||||||||
Eugene B. Shanks, Jr. |
$100,000 | $160,000 | $20,000 | $280,000 | ||||||||||||
Theodore E. Shasta |
$100,000 | $160,000 | $17,000 | $277,000 | ||||||||||||
David H. Sidwell |
$100,000 | $160,000 | $20,000 | $280,000 | ||||||||||||
Olivier Steimer |
$115,000 | $160,000 | $28,729 | $303,729 | ||||||||||||
James M. Zimmerman |
$127,500 | $100,000 | $20,000 | $247,500 |
1 | This column reflects restricted stock awards earned during 2016. The restricted stock awards were granted at the 2016 and 2015 annual general meeting, respectively, and vest at the subsequent year annual general meeting. The grant date fair value of the restricted stock awards for 2016 are based on the Common Share value of $124.85 and amount to $160,058 for each director. This amount does not include Common Shares received in lieu of cash for annual retainer or committee retainer fees earned, which are described in footnotes three and four to this table. |
2 | Beginning in 2009, we stopped using deferred restricted stock units to compensate our directors. However, certain of our longer-serving directors continue to receive dividends from deferred restricted stock units issued before 2009. When we pay dividends on our deferred restricted stock units, we issue stock units equivalent in value to the dividend payments that they would have received if they held stock. The fair value of the dividend payment on deferred restricted stock units for each director is as follows: Mr. Atieh ($88,950), Ms. Cirillo ($37,038), Mr. Hernandez ($64,998), Mr. Menikoff ($104,099), Mr. Mullin ($14,516), and Mr. Steimer ($8,973). The number of vested stock units and associated dividend payment accruals that each director held at December 31, 2016 was: Mr. Atieh (33,161), Ms. Cirillo (13,808), Mr. Hernandez (24,231), Mr. Menikoff (nil), Mr. Mullin (5,412), and Mr. Steimer (3,345). Prior to the merger, Ms. Burke, Dr. Cash and Mr. Kellner received deferred Market Value Units from Chubb Corp. Each unit has the equivalent value of one share of our common stock. These units are credited with market value units equivalent in value to the dividend payments they would have received if they held stock. The fair value of the dividend payment on deferred Market Value Units is as follows: Ms. Burke ($20,032), Dr. Cash ($6,355) and Mr. Kellner ($3,609). The number of vested Market Value Units at December 31, 2016 was: Ms. Burke (9,881), Dr. Cash (3,135) and Mr. Kellner (1,779). |
Other annual compensation also includes matching contributions made under our matching contribution program for directors (pursuant to which we match director charitable contributions to registered charities, churches and other places of worship or schools up to a maximum amount, which was $20,000 per year in 2016), personal use of Company aircraft, spousal travel and entertainment and retirement gifts. |
3 | Included in Ms. Cirillos stock awards are the following amounts which were paid in stock, rather than cash, at the election of the director: an annual retainer fee of $100,000 for which she received 801 restricted stock awards and a committee chair retainer of $12,000 for which she received 96 restricted stock awards. |
4 | Included in stock awards is an annual retainer fee of $100,000 for which the director received 801 restricted stock awards, rather than cash, at the election of the director. |
5 | Mr. Kellner joined our Board in January 2016 in connection with the closing of the Chubb Corp. acquisition and resigned from our Board in December 2016. Mr. Menikoff retired from our Board upon the expiration of his term at the May 2016 annual general meeting. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 67
How Many Shares Do Our Directors, Nominees And Executive Officers Own?
The following table sets forth information, as of March 17, 2017, with respect to the beneficial ownership of Common Shares by our NEOs, by each of our directors and by all our directors and executive officers as a group. Unless otherwise indicated, the named individual has sole voting and investment power over the Common Shares listed in the Common Shares Beneficially Owned column. The Common Shares listed for each director and each NEO, and for all directors and executive officers as a group, constitute less than one percent of the outstanding Common Shares.
Name of Beneficial Owner | Common Shares Beneficially Owned |
Common Shares Subject to Options1 |
Restricted Common Shares2 |
|||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg3 4 7 8 |
1,033,056 | 1,054,125 | 250,891 | |||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft4 7 |
239,949 | 92,293 | 53,938 | |||||||||
John W. Keogh7 |
113,046 | 169,921 | 100,223 | |||||||||
Paul J. Krump7 9 10 |
63,558 | | 21,713 | |||||||||
John J. Lupica3 7 |
106,705 | 91,435 | 73,243 | |||||||||
Michael G. Atieh3 5 6 |
18,708 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
Sheila P. Burke11 12 |
198 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
James I. Cash11 12 |
| | 1,282 | |||||||||
Mary Cirillo6 |
17,027 | | 2,179 | |||||||||
Michael P. Connors |
9,233 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
John A. Edwardson |
3,696 | | 2,083 | |||||||||
Robert M. Hernandez5 6 |
71,045 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
Leo F. Mullin6 |
12,252 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
Kimberly A. Ross |
3,728 | | 2,083 | |||||||||
Robert W. Scully3 |
23,921 | | 2,083 | |||||||||
Eugene B. Shanks, Jr. |
6,323 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
Theodore E. Shasta |
8,310 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
David H. Sidwell |
6,104 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
Olivier Steimer6 |
12,981 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
James M. Zimmerman12 |
3,271 | | 1,282 | |||||||||
All directors and executive officers as a group (24 individuals) |
2,032,002 | 1,687,511 | 659,226 |
1 | Represents Common Shares that the individual has the right to acquire within 60 days of March 17, 2017 through option exercises. |
2 | Represents Common Shares with respect to which the individual has the power to vote (but not to dispose of). |
3 | Messrs. Atieh, Greenberg, Lupica and Scully share with other persons the power to vote and/or dispose of 341 shares, 129,102 shares, 35,700 shares and 2,775 shares, respectively, of the Common Shares listed. Of the Common Shares listed as held by all directors and executive officers as a group (including those in the immediately preceding sentence), the power to vote and/or dispose of 171,253 Common Shares is shared with other persons. |
4 | Mr. Greenberg has pledged 240,000 of the Common Shares beneficially owned by him and Mr. Bancroft has pledged 41,000 of the Common Shares beneficially owned by him. In each case, such pledging is consistent with the restriction on share pledging adopted by the Company and described under Executive CompensationCompensation Discussion & AnalysisShare Pledging. |
5 | Included in these amounts are Common Shares that will be issued to the director immediately upon his or her termination from the Board. These Common Shares relate to vested stock units granted as directors compensation and associated dividend reinvestment accruals. The number of such Common Shares at March 17, 2017 included in the above table for each director is as follows: Mr. Atieh (14,190) and Mr. Hernandez (10,582). |
6 | Not included in these amounts are Common Shares that will be issued to the director no earlier than six months following his or her termination from the Board. Such Common Shares relate to deferred restricted stock units granted as directors compensation and associated dividend reinvestment accruals. The number of such Common Shares at March 17, 2017 not included in the above table for each director is as follows: Mr. Atieh (19,145), Ms. Cirillo (13,880), Mr. Hernandez (13,776), Mr. Mullin (5,440), and Mr. Steimer (3,362). |
7 | Not included in these amounts are Restricted Common Shares representing a premium performance award with respect to the performance restricted stock awards granted in 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017. Such Restricted Common Shares will vest on the fourth anniversary of the date of the award, subject to the satisfaction of certain service and performance based criteria. Shares will not be entitled to vote until vested. Dividends will be accumulated and distributed only when, and to the extent, that the shares have vested. The number of such Restricted Common Shares at March 17, 2017 not included in the above table for each NEO is as follows: Mr. Greenberg (244,988), Mr. Bancroft (36,163), Mr. Keogh (80,326), Mr. Krump (13,650) and Mr. Lupica (50,944). |
8 | Not included in these amounts are Restricted Stock Unit (RSU) awards granted in 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017. Such RSUs will vest evenly over four years. RSUs will not be entitled to vote until vested. Upon vesting, one Common Share will be delivered for each vested RSU. The number of such RSUs at March 17, 2017 not included in the above table for Mr. Greenberg is 38,284 shares. |
9 | Included in these amounts are 4,393 shares that were allocated to Mr. Krump pursuant to the Chubb Corp. Employee Stock Ownership Plan. Not included are 9,685 fully vested Deferred Stock Units, but will not be payable, unless further deferred, until 6 months after separation from service. |
10 | Not included in these amounts are Restricted Stock Unit (RSU) awards and Performance Stock Unit (PSU) awards granted in 2015 by Chubb Corp. Such RSUs and PSUs will vest: (i) 26,875 on February 25, 2018 and (ii) 20,538 on December 17, 2018. RSUs and PSUs will not be entitled to vote until vested. Upon vesting, one Common Share will be delivered for each vested RSU and PSU. The number of such RSUs and PSUs at March 17, 2017 not included in the above table for Mr. Krump is 47,413 shares. |
68 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Information About Our Share Ownership How Many Shares Do Our Directors, Nominees And Executive Officers Own?
11 | Not included in these amounts are fully vested Market Value Units payable in Common Shares that will be paid out 3 months after separation from service, unless further deferred by the director. The number of such Common Shares at March 17, 2017 for each director is as follows: Ms. Burke (9,932) and Dr. Cash (3,151). |
12 | Not included in these amounts are fully vested Deferred Stock Units, but will not be payable, unless further deferred by the participant, until the 90th day after the earliest to occur of the directors (i) death, (ii) disability, or (iii) separation from service. The number of such Common Shares at March 17, 2017 for each director is as follows: Ms. Burke (28,837), Dr. Cash (16,051) and Mr. Zimmerman (17,078). |
Which Shareholders Own More Than Five Percent Of Our Shares?
The following table sets forth information regarding each person, including corporate groups, known to us to own beneficially or of record more than five percent of our outstanding Common Shares as of December 31, 2016.
Name and Address of Beneficial Owner | Number of Shares Beneficially Owned |
Percent of Class |
||||||
Wellington Management Group LLP1 |
33,228,648 | 7.14% | ||||||
280 Congress Street Boston, Massachusetts 02210 |
||||||||
The Vanguard Group2 |
32,618,724 | 7.0% | ||||||
100 Vanguard Blvd. Malvern, Pennsylvania 19355 |
||||||||
FMR LLC3 |
29,703,132 | 6.38% | ||||||
245 Summer Street Boston, Massachusetts 02210 |
||||||||
BlackRock Inc.4 |
28,492,085 | 6.1% | ||||||
55 East 52nd Street New York, New York 10055 |
||||||||
Capital World Investors5 |
23,448,895 | 5.0% | ||||||
333 South Hope Street Los Angeles, California 90071 |
1 | Based on a Schedule 13G filed by Wellington Management Group LLP on February 9, 2017. Wellington Management may be deemed to have had beneficial ownership of 33,228,648 shares of common stock that are owned by investment advisory clients, none of which is known to have such interest with respect to more than five percent of the class of shares. Wellington Management had shared voting authority over 10,732,557 shares and shared dispositive power over 33,228,648 shares. |
2 | Based on a Schedule 13G/A filed by The Vanguard Group on February 10, 2017. The Vanguard Group, together with certain of its wholly-owned subsidiaries acting as investment managers, may be deemed to have had beneficial ownership of 32,618,724 shares of common stock. The Vanguard Group had shared voting power over 96,546 shares, sole voting power over 731,385 shares, sole dispositive power over 31,795,778 shares, and shared dispositive power over 822,946 shares. |
3 | Based on a Schedule 13G/A filed by FMR LLC on February 14, 2017. FMR LLC, together with certain of its subsidiaries, affiliates and other companies, may be deemed to have had beneficial ownership of 29,703,132 shares of common stock. No one person is known to have had an interest in more than five percent of the class of shares. FMR LLC had sole voting power over 4,094,858 shares and sole dispositive power over 29,703,132 shares. |
4 | Based on a Schedule 13G/A filed by BlackRock Inc. on January 23, 2017. BlackRock, together with certain of its affiliates, may be deemed to have had beneficial ownership of 28,492,085 shares of common stock. No one person was known to have an interest with respect to more than five percent of the class of shares. BlackRock had sole voting power over 23,630,282 shares. |
5 | Based on a Schedule 13G/A filed by Capital World Investors, a division of Capital Research and Management Company, on February 14, 2017. Capital World Investors may be deemed to have had beneficial ownership of 23,448,895 shares of common stock as a result of Capital Research and Management Company acting as investment advisor to various investment companies registered under Section 8 of the Investment Company Act of 1940. Capital World Investors disclaimed beneficial ownership of the shares pursuant to Rule 13d-4. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 69
The Compensation Committee has reviewed and discussed the Compensation Discussion & Analysis contained in this proxy statement with management. Based on our review and discussions with management, the Compensation Committee recommended to the Board of Directors that the Compensation Discussion & Analysis be included in this proxy statement for the 2017 Annual General Meeting and the Companys Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2016.
This report has been approved by all members of the Committee.
Michael P. Connors, Chair
Mary Cirillo
Robert M. Hernandez
Robert W. Scully
James M. Zimmerman
70 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 71
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
Our discussion in this Executive Summary includes certain financial measures considered in connection with compensation decisions that are not presented in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the U.S. (U.S. GAAP), known as non-GAAP financial measures, as defined by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These non-GAAP financial measures include operating income, operating return on equity, P&C and As If P&C combined ratio, and tangible book value per share. More information on the rationale for the use of these measures and reconciliations to U.S. GAAP can be found in Non-GAAP Financial Measures on page 126 in this proxy statement.
Overview
Our Board is proud of Chubbs truly outstanding management team, led by our CEO, Evan Greenberg. As it has for many years, our management team delivered superior performance in 2016 on an absolute and relative basis exceeding our own high financial goals, outperforming peers and delivering substantial value to shareholders. Significantly, these results came as the management team was transforming the Company through the integration of ACE Limited (ACE) and The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp.) into the largest publicly-traded property and casualty insurance company in the world, with operations in 54 countries and a market value of more than $60 billion.
The Boards compensation recommendations for 2016 reflect both this success and the Companys philosophy to closely link compensation to performance, ensuring that our leadership team remains highly motivated, and strongly aligning remuneration outcomes with the creation of shareholder value. The success of this philosophy is demonstrated not only in this years results, but in consistently high financial, operating and stock price performance over time. Over the past decade, under Evan Greenbergs leadership, the Company has had outstanding growth in tangible book value per share, an industry-leading combined ratio and top-quartile Total Shareholder Return (TSR).
While our compensation system has served us well, we made significant enhancements this year reflecting best practice and our extensive shareholder outreach. We listened to our shareholders and incorporated their feedback to make our pay-for-performance and shareholder alignment even stronger.
What We Heard |
What We Did | |||
Performance share earning period should be longer-term, with cliff-vesting |
|
Moved to 3-year cliff-vesting, eliminated 4-year | ||
Eliminate second chance look-back for performance shares |
|
Eliminated look-back in new performance awards for 2017 and going forward | ||
Consider using multiple metrics (including TSR) for performance share vesting |
|
Added P&C combined ratio to tangible book value per share as new performance share metric | ||
Added TSR modifier for premium performance share awards | ||||
Premium share target (200%) seems too high |
|
Reduced maximum target to 165% | ||
Additional detail on CEO pay decision would be helpful |
|
Included more specifics regarding link between performance and CEO pay |
72 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
Our CEO Compensation Process
Our CEO, Evan Greenberg, has led the Company to extraordinary success over his 13-year tenure. That success continued in 2016 with exceptional financial and strategic results. His compensation reflects that success.
Each year, the Compensation Committee sets a scorecard for the potential range of CEO compensation, with top-, middle- and low-end bands tied to achievement of specific financial, operational and strategic goals, considered together with TSR, as reflected in the following summary for 2016:
* | Includes $4 million special one-time grant of performance shares in recognition of substantial additional work associated with the pre-closing phase of the Chubb Corp. acquisition. The grant was part of our Compensation Committees final compensation awards applicable to 2015; however, in accordance with SEC rules, this one-time grant is included in certain 2016 compensation tables that follow because the grant date was in February 2016. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 73
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
Why Vote For Say-on-Pay?
Our Board recommends that you vote For the approval of our Swiss say-on-pay and non-binding SEC say-on-pay proposals. In support of these recommendations, we highlight the following key factors:
Strong financial performance both in absolute terms and relative to our peers, including:
Outstanding strategic and tactical success in creating the worlds largest publicly traded P&C insurance company through the merger of ACE and Chubb Corp., with integration savings and synergies realized ahead of schedule and above initial projections, including:
We listened to our shareholders and made changes to our executive compensation program for 2017 to ensure a continued strong link between pay and performance and increased transparency (see page 72 for details on the changes).
* | 2016 As If results include the combined companys results for the first 14 days of January and exclude any impact from purchase accounting adjustments related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition. 2015 As If results include legacy ACE plus legacy Chubb historical results. We acquired Chubb Corp. on January 14, 2016. |
How Our Compensation Program Works
What We Reward
Superior operating and financial performance, as measured against our peers, prior year and Board-approved plan
Achievement of strategic goals
Superior underwriting and risk management in all our business activities |
|
How We Link Pay to Performance
Core link: Performance measured across 4 key metrics, against peers, prior year and Board- approved plan Tangible book value per share growth Operating return on equity Operating income P&C combined ratio
TSR modifier in addition to metrics and strategic scorecard
Consideration of strategic achievements, including execution of key non-financial objectives |
|
How We Paid
$19.8 million CEO reported pay
Down vs. 2015, inclusive of one-time $4 million performance share grant determined in February 2016 in connection with Chubb Corp. acquisition pre-closing and integration planning
Other NEO reported pay
Down vs. 2015, inclusive of one-time performance share grants determined in February 2016 in connection with Chubb Corp. acquisition pre-closing and integration planning
|
74 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
Compensation Profile
Approximately 93 percent of our CEOs and 86 percent of our other NEOs total direct compensation is variable or at-risk.*
* | Excluding the special one-time long-term incentive equity awards granted to the CEO and the other NEOs in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition. |
How We Use Peer Groups
We utilize two peer groups in order to (1) assess our financial performance against key metrics relative to our P&C insurance industry peers (Financial Performance Peer Group) and (2) align our compensation with U.S. companies of comparable size and complexity that we seek to be competitive with for talent and compensation purposes (Compensation Benchmarking Peer Group).
Financial Performance Peer Group |
Compensation Benchmarking Peer Group | |||||
American International Group, Inc.
CNA Financial Corporation
The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc.
The Travelers Companies, Inc.
XL Group plc
Zurich Financial Services Group |
The Allstate Corporation
American Express Company
American International Group, Inc.
Aon plc
Bank of America Corporation
The Bank of New York Mellon
BlackRock, Inc.
Cigna Corp.
|
Citigroup Inc.
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc.
MetLife, Inc.
Morgan Stanley
Prudential Financial, Inc.
The Travelers Companies, Inc. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 75
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
Long-Term Performance Highlights
Chubb has a distinguished, long-term track record of performance and outperformance relative to its insurance industry peers. The following charts reflect our performance across key financial and operating measures starting in 2004 when Evan Greenberg became CEO of the Company.
Operating Income |
Operating ROE | |
2004-2016 Operating Income against Financial Performance Peer Group average (indexed to Chubb 2004 operating income)* | 2004-2016 Operating ROE against Financial Performance Peer Group average | |
![]() |
![]() | |
* Chubb operating income grew from $1 billion in 2004 to $4.7 billion in 2016 (377%). Average peer generated only $553 million of operating income in 2016 for every $1 billion of operating income in 2004 (-45%). Zurich is presented with net income because it does not use operating income as a financial measure. |
||
Total Shareholder Return |
P&C Combined Ratio | |
2004-2016 TSR against Financial Performance Peer Group average* | 2004-2016 P&C CR against Financial Performance Peer Group average | |
![]() |
![]() | |
* An investment in one Chubb share on January 1, 2004 ($41.15) was worth $174.05 at December 31, 2016 (including dividend reinvestment), versus $105.59 for the same amount invested in the average share of our peers.
|
Source: SNL and company disclosures
Book Value per Share & Tangible Book Value per Share
2004-2016 BVPS and TBVPS
76 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
2016 Performance: Key Metrics
The Compensation Committee evaluates our performance across the following key metrics relative to our Financial Performance Peer Group, Board-approved plan and prior year.
Our average relative performance across the metrics described below exceeded the 90th percentile of our Financial Performance Peer Group.
Book value per share growth & Tangible book value per share growth |
15.4% | Book value per share growth exceeded plan and prior year | ||
-16.1% | The decrease in tangible book value per share growth is reflective of the expected 29.3% dilution at the closing of the Chubb Corp. acquisition. Tangible book value per share grew 13.2 points from the closing through the end of 2016 and exceeded plan. Adjusted for the Chubb Corp. acquisition, tangible book value per share growth was in the 100th percentile and exceeded each member of our Financial Performance Peer Group | |||
Operating return |
10.5% | Relative performance was above the 80th percentile of our Financial Performance Peer Group. Absolute performance exceeded plan but was down compared to 11.5% in 2015 | ||
Operating income |
$4.7B | Relative performance was in the upper quartile of our Financial Performance Peer Group. Absolute performance exceeded plan, and exceeded prior year by 47% | ||
P&C
combined |
88.7% |
Relative performance was in the 100th percentile and exceeded each member of our Financial Performance Peer Group, as well as plan. P&C combined ratio increased compared to 87.4% (87.5% on an As If basis) in 2015 | ||
Total Shareholder Return |
16% 1-year 11% 3-year |
Relative to our Financial Performance Peer Group, 1-year TSR was in the 73rd percentile and 3-year TSR was in the 76th percentile. Both 1-year TSR and 3-year TSR exceeded plan and prior year |
2016 Strategic Achievements
Chubb continued to invest in the future of the Company consistent with our strategic goals:
| Completed the largest merger in insurance history through our acquisition of Chubb Corp., creating the worlds largest publicly traded P&C insurance company |
| Executed on a transformational company-wide global integration effort; integration savings ($325 million in 2016) and synergies realized ($800 million by end of 2018) ahead of schedule and above initial projections |
| Launched new commercial specialty product division while maintaining excellence in our core business of underwriting and servicing customers and distribution partners, retaining our commercial and personal lines customers at or above all-time highs |
| Continued to expand analytics and use of predictive modeling to support underwriting, marketing, sales and claims |
Payfor-Performance Framework
Each NEO has an annual cash incentive and long-term incentive opportunity.
Annual Cash Incentive | Long-Term/Equity Incentive | |||
CEO |
05X base salary |
09X base salary | ||
Other NEOs |
03X base salary |
05X base salary |
To fall in the upper end of the ranges described above, relative Company performance must fall in the upper quartile of the Financial Performance Peer Group and absolute performance must exceed plan and prior year. The above ranges may be exceeded in the judgment of the Compensation Committee if relative Company performance substantially exceeds the Financial Performance Peer Group and absolute performance substantially exceeds plan and prior year.
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 77
Executive Compensation Executive Summary
2016 Compensation Decisions
Using our pay-for-performance framework, and recognizing both the outstanding 2016 results as measured by the key metrics, as well as the Companys strategic achievements, including the integration of ACE and Chubb entities into the worlds largest publicly-traded P&C company, the Compensation Committee determined to award cash bonuses and equity awards at the top end of the pay-for-performance framework. Specifically, our Compensation Committee awarded an annual cash bonus to our CEO at 4.7X base salary and to our other NEOs at 1.9X to 2.9X base salary, and granted long-term incentive equity awards to our CEO at 8.4X base salary and our other NEOs at 2.9X to 4.9X base salary.
78 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Compensation Program Overview
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 79
Executive Compensation Compensation Program Overview
Components of Total Direct Compensation
Each NEO has a total direct compensation opportunity, which we deliver through three components that constitute what we refer to as total direct compensation:
Total direct compensation
Component | What We Reward | Target Opportunity Range | What It Achieves | |||||
![]() |
Base salary |
Annual base salary, which is closely tied to role and market. | Base salary is targeted at the median of our compensation peer group and industry peers.
|
Provides a competitive market-based level of fixed compensation. | ||||
![]() |
Cash bonus |
Each NEOs annual cash bonus is based on the prior years performance, as measured against:
Individual Performance Criteria;
Company Performance Criteria; and
for some NEOs, the performance of the operating unit(s) directly managed by the NEO.
|
The specific annual cash bonus opportunity for each NEO ranges between zero and 300 percent of annual base salary based on performance.
The specific annual cash bonus opportunity for the CEO ranges between zero to 500 percent based on performance. |
Ties officer pay to annual corporate and individual performance. | ||||
Long-term incentive equity awards
Stock options (time-based)
Restricted stock (time-based)
Performance-based restricted stock
Target Awards Premium Awards |
The value of each NEOs long-term incentive compensation award is based on the prior years performance, as measured against:
Individual Performance Criteria;
Company Performance Criteria; and
for some NEOs, the performance of the operating unit(s) directly managed by the NEO.
The ultimate value realized from these awards is based on the Companys stock price and per share tangible book value performance over time. For performance-based awards granted in 2017 and thereafter, P&C combined ratio is added as additional vesting criteria, with a TSR modifier for Premium Awards.
|
The value of the award is determined as a percentage of annual base salary. This varies greatly among NEOs depending on position and performance but has been targeted to be between 200 percent and 500 percent of annual base salary.
The value of the award for the CEO may go up to 900 percent of annual base salary. |
Ties the current years awards to future performance.
The Committee determines a specific long-term incentive equity award for each NEO that is linked both to current year performance and multi-year future performance.
Stock options reward stock price appreciation.
Restricted stock (time-based) aligns executive interests with those of shareholders, provides ownership and supports executive retention.
Performance-based restricted stock encourages superior growth in tangible book value and strong P&C combined ratio. |
Other Compensation
NEOs automatically participate in Company-sponsored qualified retirement plans. They are also eligible to participate in Company-sponsored non-qualified deferred compensation plans. Under the non-qualified deferred compensation plans, the NEOs may elect to defer annual base salary and annual cash bonus and direct those deferrals to investment options that mirror those offered in our qualified defined contribution plans, to the extent permissible under applicable tax laws.
80 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Compensation Program Overview
Our NEOs do not participate in any Company-sponsored defined benefit plans, which are often referred to as pension plans, other than Mr. Krump, who participates in the Chubb Corp. pension plans assumed by the Company in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition. For more information, see Pension Benefits on page 106.
Perquisites are not considered part of total direct compensation. They are discussed in footnote 4 of the Summary Compensation Table beginning on page 99.
Compensation Practices and Policies
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 81
Executive Compensation The Relationship of Compensation to Risk
The Relationship of Compensation to Risk
82 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation The Relationship of Compensation to Risk
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 83
Executive Compensation How We Use Peer Group Data in Determining Compensation
How We Use Peer Group Data in Determining Compensation
84 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation How We Use Peer Group Data in Determining Compensation
How We Determine Total Direct Compensation Pay Mix
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 85
Executive Compensation How We Determine Total Direct Compensation Pay Mix
Criteria and Vesting Schedules
Each year the Compensation Committee reviews the vesting criteria for Executive Management and NEOs. For all grants awarded after August 2014, all members of Executive Management and our NEOs have double-trigger vesting upon a change in control. Paul J. Krump was not an employee of the Company until January 2016 and therefore all of his awards have double-trigger vesting upon a change in control.
Vesting Criteria Under a Change in Control
| ||||||
Single-Trigger Vesting | Modified Single Trigger Vesting | Double-Trigger Vesting | ||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
Before May 2011 | After May 2011 | After August 2014 | |||
John W. Keogh |
Before August 2014 | n/a | After August 2014 | |||
John J. Lupica |
Before August 2014 | n/a | After August 2014 | |||
Philip V. Bancroft |
Before February 2013 | After February 2013 | After August 2014 |
86 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation How We Determine Total Direct Compensation Pay Mix
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 87
Executive Compensation How We Determine Total Direct Compensation Pay Mix
88 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation How We Determine Total Direct Compensation Pay Mix
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 89
Executive Compensation How We Determine and Approve NEO Compensation
How We Determine and Approve NEO Compensation
90 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation How We Determine and Approve NEO Compensation
How We Determine Compensation For Our CEO
Each year, the Compensation Committee sets a scorecard for the potential range of CEO compensation, with top-, middle- and low-end bands tied to achievement of specific financial, operational and strategic goals, considered together with TSR, as reflected in the following summary for 2016:
* | Includes $4 million special one-time grant of performance shares in recognition of substantial additional work associated with the pre-closing phase of the Chubb Corp. acquisition. The grant was part of our Compensation Committees final compensation awards applicable to 2015; however, in accordance with SEC rules, this one-time grant is included in certain 2016 compensation tables that follow because the grant date was in February 2016. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 91
Executive Compensation How We Determine and Approve NEO Compensation
How We Determine Other NEO Compensation
2016 NEO Total Direct Compensation and Performance Summary
Below we provide a summary of each of our named executive officers total direct compensation and an overview of their 2016 performance relative to achieving our annual and long-term performance goals. The process the Compensation Committee uses to determine each officers 2016 compensation is described more fully in How We Determine and Approve NEO Compensation beginning on page 90.
CEO 2016 Total Direct Compensation
Evan G. Greenberg
Chairman, President and CEO
92 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation 2016 NEO Total Direct Compensation and Performance Summary
2016 Total Direct Compensation-Variable Pay Mix Variable Compensation Long-term Incentive Awards $11,800,000 Stock Options $2,950,000 Restricted Stock $2,212,000 Performance Shares $6,638,000 Total Long-Term Equity Compensation Annual Incentive Award $6,600,000 Fixed Compensation Total Annual Cash Compensation Base salary $1,400,000
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 93
Executive Compensation 2016 NEO Total Direct Compensation and Performance Summary
Other NEO 2016 Total Direct Compensation
2016 Total Direct Compensation-Variable Pay Mix Variable Compensation Long-term Incentive Awards $2,500,000 Stock Options $625,000 Restricted Stock $750,000 Performance Shares $1,125,000 Annual Incentive Award $1,470,000 Total Long-Term Equity Compensation Fixed Compensation Base salary $768,750 Total Annual Cash Compensation
94 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation 2016 NEO Total Direct Compensation and Performance Summary
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 95
2016 Total Direct Compensation-Variable Pay Mix Variable Compensation Long-term Incentive Awards $4,350,000 Stock Options
$1,087,500 Restricted Stock $1,109,250 Performance Shares $2,153,250 Total Long-Term Equity Compensation Annual Incentive Award $2,610,000 Fixed Compensation Base salary $896,111 Total Annual Cash Compensation
2016 Total Direct Compensation-Variable Pay Mix Variable Compensation Long-term Incentive Equity $2,450,000 Stock Options $612,500 Restricted Stock $735,000 Performance Shares
$1,102,500 Total Long-Term Equity Compensation Annual Incentive Award $1,760,000 Fixed Compensation Base salary $840,000 Total Annual Cash Compensation
Executive Compensation 2016 NEO Total Direct Compensation and Performance Summary
2016 Total Direct Compensation Supplemental Table
Each February, the Compensation Committee and the Board of Directors approve compensation for each NEO including any adjustments to annual base salary, annual cash bonus in recognition of prior calendar years performance and long-term incentive equity awards. The long-term incentive equity awards consist of stock options, valued using a notional Black Scholes option valuation methodology representing roughly 25 percent of the closing market price at the date of grant; time-based restricted stock awards; and performance shares, which are subject to performance-based vesting criteria, valued at the closing market price at the date of grant.
The key compensation components for each of our NEOs are summarized in the charts below. The totals and the equity award values do not directly correlate to what is ultimately reported in the Summary Compensation Table in accordance with SEC rules (for example, the equity award columns below reflect February 2017 grants, while the Summary Compensation Table reflects February 2016 grants). However, using the above methodology, they do reflect how the Compensation Committee considers the overall impact of each annual compensation component as of the time of determination.
2016 Named Executive Officers Compensation Supplemental Table
Name and Title/Business Unit | Annual Base Salary |
Annual Cash Bonus |
Annual Long Term Incentive Equity Award |
Total Direct Compensation |
||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | $1,400,000 | $6,600,000 | $11,800,000 | $19,800,000 | ||||||||||||
Chairman, President and CEO | ||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft1 | $768,750 | $1,470,000 | $2,500,000 | $4,738,750 | ||||||||||||
Chief Financial Officer | ||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh2 | $896,111 | $2,610,000 | $4,350,000 | $7,856,111 | ||||||||||||
Executive Vice Chairman and Chief Operating Officer |
||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump | $840,000 | $1,760,000 | $2,450,000 | $5,050,000 | ||||||||||||
President, North America Commercial and Personal Insurance | ||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica3 | $793,519 | $1,980,000 | $3,330,000 | $6,103,519 | ||||||||||||
Vice Chairman; President, North America Major Accounts and Specialty Insurance |
1 | Mr. Bancrofts annual base salary was increased for 2017 to $800,000. |
2 | Mr. Keoghs annual base salary was increased for 2017 to $925,000. |
3 | Mr. Lupicas annual base salary was increased for 2017 to $820,000. |
96 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
2016 Total Direct Compensation-Variable Pay Mix Variable Compensation Long-term Incentive Awards $3,330,000 Stock Options $832,500 Restricted Stock $999,000 Performance Shares $1,498,500 Total Long-Term Equity Compensation Annual Incentive Award $1,980,000 Fixed Compensation Base salary $793,519 Total Annual Cash Compensation
Executive Compensation Defined Terms and Calculations
Defined Terms and Calculations
The non-GAAP financial measures used in this Compensation Discussion & Analysis (operating income, operating return on equity, P&C and As If P&C combined ratio and tangible book value per common share) are defined and reconciled to U.S. GAAP in the Non-GAAP Measures section of this proxy statement.
Book Value Per Common Share
|
shareholders equity divided by the number of Common Shares outstanding
| |
Combined Ratio |
the amount that an insurer must pay to cover claims and expenses for every dollar of earned premium. It is the sum of the expense ratio and the loss ratio
| |
Company Performance Criteria
|
the factors described on page 79 that measure the Companys performance for purposes of determining an individuals compensation
| |
Compensation
Benchmarking
|
those companies identified on page 84 who the Company considers for purposes of comparing and determining executive compensation
| |
Double-Trigger Vesting
|
all unvested equity vests immediately upon a change in control if the executive is terminated without cause or resigns for good reason between six months before and two years after such change in control
| |
Expense Ratio
|
expense ratio = policy acquisition costs and administrative expenses
net earned premium
| |
Financial Performance
Peer
|
those companies identified on page 85 who the Company considers to be comparable from a business perspective
| |
Individual Performance Criteria
|
the factors described on page 79 that measure an individuals performance for purposes of determining such individuals compensation
| |
Loss Ratio
|
loss ratio = losses incurred net earned premiums
| |
Modified Single-Trigger
|
all unvested equity vests:
(a) immediately upon a change in control if the executive is terminated without cause or resigns for good reason between six months before and six months after such change in control; or
(b) immediately upon the executives resignation for any reason after remaining a company executive for at least six months after a change in control, provided that such resignation occurs between six months and two years after a change in control
| |
Premium Award
|
performance-based restricted stock awards in excess of the yearly Target Award in the event that the Companys cumulative performance exceeds the 50th percentile, as further described on page 88
| |
Single-Trigger Vesting
|
all unvested equity vests immediately upon a change in control
| |
Target Award
|
performance-based restricted stock awards consisting of, for awards granted prior to January 2017, four annual installments, and for awards granted beginning January 2017 and thereafter, a three-year cliff vesting period, subject in each case to specified vesting criteria described on page 87
| |
Total Shareholder Return
|
stock price increase plus dividends reinvested
| |
Total Direct Compensation
|
base salary, cash bonus and long-term incentive equity awards
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 97
Executive Compensation Acronyms
Acronyms
CEO
|
Chief Executive Officer
| |
CFO
|
Chief Financial Officer
| |
COO
|
Chief Operating Officer
| |
NEOs |
Executive officers whose compensation is required to be disclosed in the proxy statement based on applicable SEC rules
| |
P&C
|
Property & casualty
|
98 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Summary Compensation Table
The following table sets forth compensation for 2016, 2015 and 2014 for our NEOs.
Name and Principal Position | Year | Salary | Bonus | Stock Awards1 |
Option Awards2 |
Change in Pension Value and Nonqualified Deferred |
All Other Compensation4 |
Total | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer |
2016 | $1,400,000 | $6,600,000 | $12,850,051 | $2,406,837 | | $1,162,598 | $24,419,486 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 | $1,351,538 | $6,600,000 | $8,849,997 | $2,371,296 | | $1,208,316 | $20,381,147 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
2014 | $1,200,000 | $6,600,000 | $8,550,004 | $2,004,856 | | $1,323,314 | $19,678,174 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft Chief Financial Officer |
2016 | $768,750 | $1,470,000 | $2,818,747 | $494,616 | | $620,577 | $6,172,690 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 | $750,000 | $1,350,000 | $1,612,429 | $432,055 | | $672,281 | $4,816,765 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
2014 | $750,000 | $1,160,000 | $1,499,974 | $351,735 | | $556,567 | $4,318,276 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh Executive Vice Chairman and Chief Operating Officer |
2016 | $896,111 | $2,610,000 | $5,174,945 | $836,266 | | $453,691 | $9,971,013 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 | $885,000 | $2,475,000 | $2,936,302 | $786,756 | | $435,861 | $7,518,919 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
2014 | $885,000 | $2,265,000 | $2,711,215 | $635,756 | | $399,658 | $6,896,629 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump President, North America Commercial and Personal Insurance |
2016 | $840,000 | $1,760,000 | $999,946 | | $2,288,521 | $152,178 | $6,040,645 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica Vice Chairman; President, North America Major Accounts and Specialty Insurance |
2016 | $793,519 | $1,980,000 | $3,962,632 | $642,511 | | $413,348 | $7,792,010 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
2015 | $775,000 | $1,855,000 | $2,268,741 | $607,895 | | $365,211 | $5,871,847 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
2014 | $775,000 | $1,700,000 | $2,043,765 | $479,237 | | $350,124 | $5,348,126 |
1 | This column discloses the aggregate grant date fair value of stock awards granted during the year. This column includes time-based as well as performance-based restricted stock for which the target amount is included. For information on performance targets and vesting, see Compensation Discussion & AnalysisPerformance-Based Restricted Stock Vesting. Additional detail regarding restricted stock awards made in 2016 is provided in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards table below in the Executive Compensation section of this proxy statement. Assuming the highest level of performance is achieved (which would result in vesting of 100 percent of performance shares awarded, i.e., all Target Awards and Premium Awards), the aggregate grant date fair value of the stock awards set forth in the table above would be: |
2016 | 2015 | 2014 | ||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
$23,487,629 | $15,487,495 | $14,962,483 | |||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft |
$4,728,141 | $2,418,644 | $2,249,961 | |||||||||||
John W. Keogh |
$9,304,388 | $4,874,248 | $4,500,598 | |||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
$1,999,892 | | | |||||||||||
John J. Lupica |
$6,743,968 | $3,403,112 | $3,065,647 |
The Target Awards granted in 2012 met relevant performance criteria and vested their annual installments as scheduled. Target Awards granted to NEOs for 2012, 2011 and 2010 earned a Premium Award of 65.5 percent, 92.71 percent and 100 percent, respectively. The table below shows the value realized on vesting of those Premium Awards at their respective four-year anniversary dates in 2016, 2015 and 2014. |
2012 Grant Vested in 2016 |
2011 Grant Vested in 2015 |
2010 Grant Vested in 2014 |
||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
$3,550,859 | $5,038,372 | $6,071,934 | |||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft |
$482,795 | $739,438 | $879,694 | |||||||||||
John W. Keogh |
$758,838 | $1,954,160 | $1,256,121 | |||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
| | | |||||||||||
John J. Lupica |
$372,552 | | |
2 | This column discloses the aggregate grant date fair value of stock option awards granted during the year. Option values are based on the grant date fair market value computed in accordance to FASB ASC Topic 718. Additional detail regarding stock option awards made in 2016 is provided in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards table elsewhere in this proxy statement. |
3 | Reflects solely the aggregate change in pension value for 2016 under the Pension Plan of The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp. Pension Plan) and the Pension Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan). Mr. Krumps benefits under the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan and Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan were $201,044 and $2,087,477, respectively. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 99
Executive Compensation Summary Compensation Table
4 | As detailed in the table below, this column includes perquisites and other personal benefits, consisting of the following: |
| Perquisites including retirement plan contributions, personal use of the Company aircraft and Company apartment, and miscellaneous other benefits detailed below. |
| We calculate our incremental cost for personal use of corporate aircraft based on our variable operating costs, including fuel, crew travel, landing/ramp fees, catering, international handling and proportional share of lease costs. We include in this table amounts for personal use of corporate aircraft by all NEOs who make personal use of the corporate aircraft, although the Board of Directors required Mr. Greenberg to use corporate aircraft for all travel whenever practicable for security reasons. For all other NEOs, personal use of the corporate aircraft was limited to space available on normally scheduled management business flights. |
| Other personal benefits including housing allowances, cost of living allowance and home leave. |
In 2016, 2015 and 2014, housing allowance was provided to Mr. Bancroft because he has been required by Chubb to maintain a second residence in Bermuda in addition to maintaining his own personal residence.
| Our contributions to retirement plans consist of matching and non-contributory employer contributions for 2016, 2015 and 2014. |
Name | Year | Housing Allowance |
Private Jet Usage |
Misc. Other |
Retirement Plan Contribution |
|||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | 2016 | | $156,220 | $46,378 | $960,000 | |||||||||||||||
2015 | | $205,364 | $48,767 | $954,185 | ||||||||||||||||
2014 | | $237,718 | $191,596 | $894,000 | ||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft | 2016 | $252,000 | | $114,327 | $254,250 | |||||||||||||||
2015 | $328,105 | | $114,976 | $229,200 | ||||||||||||||||
2014 | $222,000 | | $110,167 | $224,400 | ||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh | 2016 | | $210 | $48,948 | $404,533 | |||||||||||||||
2015 | | $12,403 | $45,458 | $378,000 | ||||||||||||||||
2014 | | | $45,418 | $354,240 | ||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump | 2016 | | | $51,606 | $100,572 | |||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica | 2016 | | $3,606 | $91,920 | $317,822 | |||||||||||||||
2015 | | | $68,211 | $297,000 | ||||||||||||||||
2014 | | $1,016 | $76,108 | $273,000 |
1 | This column consists of the following: (i) for Mr. Greenberg, residential security system reimbursement, use of corporate apartment, executive medical coverage and matching contributions made under our matching charitable contributions program; and (ii) for all other NEOs, club memberships, financial planning, executive medical coverage, use of corporate apartment, matching contributions made under our matching charitable contributions program, car allowance or car lease and car maintenance allowance. |
Each of our NEOs receives an annual salary with annual discretionary cash and long-term incentives. Base salaries for NEOs are adjusted as described in Compensation Discussion & Analysis. Each NEO also receives customary executive benefits, such as participation in our current benefit and insurance plans, and certain perquisites, which may include some or all of a housing allowance, car allowance, car loan and club dues. We entered into an individual offer letter with each NEO at the beginning of his respective employment. Other than as described above, no material terms of such offer letters remain in effect.
In 2015, our Executive Management entered into non-compete agreements that are described below under the Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change in Control table.
In addition, in connection with the Companys re-domestication to Switzerland in 2008, and for the sole purpose of documentation of work that is expected to be performed in Switzerland, the Company entered into employment agreements with Evan G. Greenberg, the Companys Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Philip Bancroft, the Companys Chief Financial Officer. Subsequent to the re-domestication, the Company entered into employment agreements with John W. Keogh and John J. Lupica, as Vice Chairmen of Chubb Limited. These employment agreements did not change these officers responsibilities to the Chubb group of companies or their aggregate compensation from the Chubb group of companies. These employment agreements formally establish that the named executive officers have responsibilities directly with Chubb Limited as a Swiss company and will receive compensation specifically for work performed in Switzerland.
These employment agreements specify that these officers:
| are employees of the Swiss parent company, |
| will receive compensation allocable to such employment agreement (as opposed to compensation allocable to their work for other Chubb companies) that reflects 10 percent of the total compensation such named executive officer is currently receiving, and |
| will work a portion of their time in Switzerland for Chubb Limited approximating 10 percent of their annual work calendar. |
100 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Summary Compensation Table
The Company may use the same form of employment agreement for these officers to allocate a percentage of their salaries to other subsidiaries of the Company.
We maintain a broad-based employee stock purchase plan, which gives our eligible employees the right to purchase our Common Shares through payroll deductions at a purchase price that reflects a 15 percent discount to the market price of our Common Shares. No participant may purchase more than ten percent of the participants compensation or $25,000 in value of Common Shares, whichever is less, under this plan in any calendar year. Of our NEOs, Paul J. Krump and John J. Lupica participated in the employee stock purchase plan in 2016. See Agenda Item 9, Approval of Amended and Restated Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan, for more information on our employee stock purchase plan.
We have entered into indemnification agreements with our directors and executive officers. These agreements are in furtherance of our Articles of Association that allow us to indemnify our directors and officers to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law as well as NYSE and SEC regulations. The indemnification agreements provide for indemnification arising out of specified indemnifiable events, such as events relating to the fact that the indemnitee is or was one of our directors or officers or is or was a director, officer, employee or agent of another entity at our request or relating to anything done or not done by the indemnitee in such a capacity, including indemnification relating to the government investigation of industry practices. The indemnification agreements provide for advancement of expenses. These agreements provide for mandatory indemnification to the extent an indemnitee is successful on the merits. The indemnification agreements set forth procedures relating to indemnification claims. To the extent we maintain general and/or directors and officers liability insurance, the agreements provide that the indemnitee shall be covered by such policies to the maximum extent of the coverage available for any of our directors or officers.
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 101
Executive Compensation Grants of Plan-Based Awards
The following table sets forth information concerning grants of plan-based awards to the NEOs during the calendar year ended December 31, 2016. Because the Compensation Committee made plan-based awards at its February 2017 meeting which it intended as compensation for 2016, we have included those grants in this table along with grants made during 2016.
Name | Grant Date1 |
Estimated Future Payouts Under |
All Other Stock Awards; Number of Shares of Stock or Units3 |
All Other Option of Securities Underlying Options4 |
Exercise or Base Price of Option Award |
Grant Date Fair Value of Equity Incentive |
||||||||||||||||||||
Target | Maximum | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
February 23, 2017 | 47,748 | 78,784 | 15,916 | $8,849,933 | |||||||||||||||||||||
February 23, 2017 | 84,892 | $139.01 | $2,183,422 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 56,065 | 112,130 | 18,688 | $8,850,008 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 99,662 | $118.39 | $2,406,837 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 33,787 | 67,574 | $4,000,043 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft |
February 23, 2017 | 8,093 | 13,353 | 5,395 | $1,874,967 | |||||||||||||||||||||
February 23, 2017 | 17,986 | $139.01 | $462,600 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 7,681 | 15,362 | 7,681 | $1,818,707 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 20,481 | $118.39 | $494,616 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 8,447 | 16,894 | $1,000,040 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh |
February 23, 2017 | 15,490 | 25,589 | 7,980 | $3,262,565 | |||||||||||||||||||||
February 23, 2017 | 31,295 | $139.01 | $804,907 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 17,142 | 34,284 | 8,831 | $3,074,943 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 34,628 | $118.39 | $836,266 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 17,738 | 35,476 | $2,100,002 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
February 23, 2017 | 7,931 | 13,086 | 5,287 | $1,837,434 | |||||||||||||||||||||
February 23, 2017 | 17,626 | $139.01 | $453,341 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
March 1, 2016 | 8,495 | 16,990 | $999,946 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica |
February 23, 2017 | 10,780 | 17,787 | 7,187 | $2,497,593 | |||||||||||||||||||||
February 23, 2017 | 23,957 | $139.01 | $616,174 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 9,978 | 19,956 | 9,978 | $2,362,591 | ||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 26,605 | $118.39 | $642,511 | |||||||||||||||||||||||
February 25, 2016 | 13,515 | 27,030 | $1,600,041 |
1 | As stated above, the Compensation Committee intended awards granted in February 2017 as compensation for 2016. The Compensation Committee intended awards granted in February 2016 as compensation for 2015. Therefore, we also disclosed these awards in our 2016 proxy statement. |
2 | The terms of the performance awards, including the performance criteria for vesting, are described in Compensation Discussion & AnalysisPerformance-Based Restricted Stock Vesting. The Target column of this table corresponds to Target Awards, and the Maximum column refers to the maximum possible Target and Premium Awards. During the restricted period, the NEOs are entitled to vote both the time-based and performance-based restricted stock. Dividends are accumulated and distributed only when the shares have vested. As a special recognition award for the Chubb Corp. acquisition pre-closing and integration planning, performance-based restricted stock awards were granted in February 2016 for Messrs. Greenberg, Bancroft, Keogh and Lupica, and in March 2016 for Mr. Krump. For Messrs. Greenberg and Keogh, any shares earned will cliff-vest at the end of the four-year period. Furthermore, to link compensation with the creation of shareholder value, for Messrs. Greenberg and Keogh, any shares above target (premium shares) will be paid out at 100 percent if the share price exceeds $130 as measured by the average price of the last 30 trading days prior to the end of the measurement period or at 50 percent if the share price does not exceed $130. |
3 | Restricted stock vests on the first, second, third and fourth anniversary dates of the grant. |
4 | Stock options vest on the first, second and third anniversary dates of the grant. |
5 | This column discloses the aggregate grant date fair market value computed in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718. For all assumptions used in the valuation, see note 12 to our consolidated financial statements included in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2016. |
102 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year End
Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year End
The following table sets forth the outstanding equity awards held by our NEOs as of December 31, 2016.
Option Awards | Stock Awards | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Name | Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options Exercisable |
Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options Unexercisable |
Option Exercise Price |
Option Date |
Number of Shares or Units of Stock That Have Not Vested |
Market Value Units of Stock |
Equity Incentive Other Rights That Have |
Equity Incentive Plan Awards: Market or Payout Value of Unearned Shares, Units or Other Rights That Have Not Vested1 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
130,640 | | $60.28 | 02/27/2018 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
169,280 | | $38.51 | 02/26/2019 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
159,820 | | $50.37 | 02/25/2020 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
134,100 | | $62.64 | 02/24/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
116,905 | | $73.35 | 02/23/2022 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
143,459 | | $85.39 | 02/28/2023 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
65,453 | 32,728 | $96.76 | 02/27/2024 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
34,260 | 68,527 | $114.78 | 02/26/2025 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 99,662 | $118.39 | 02/25/2026 | 54,183 | $7,158,658 | 196,333 | $25,939,516 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft |
2,596 | | $38.51 | 02/26/2019 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1,985 | | $50.37 | 02/25/2020 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
18,459 | | $62.64 | 02/24/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
14,911 | | $73.35 | 02/23/2022 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
17,809 | | $85.39 | 02/28/2023 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
11,481 | 5,744 | $96.76 | 02/27/2024 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
6,241 | 12,487 | $114.78 | 02/26/2025 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 20,481 | $118.39 | 02/25/2026 | 19,512 | $2,577,925 | 29,239 | $3,863,057 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh |
19,082 | | $60.28 | 02/27/2018 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
24,944 | | $62.64 | 02/24/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
7,391 | | $63.42 | 08/11/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
23,432 | | $73.35 | 02/23/2022 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
29,665 | | $85.39 | 02/28/2023 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
20,753 | 10,381 | $96.76 | 02/27/2024 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
11,366 | 22,737 | $114.78 | 02/26/2025 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 34,628 | $118.39 | 02/25/2026 | 24,593 | $3,249,227 | 63,396 | $8,375,880 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
| | 76,463 | $10,102,292 | 8,495 | $1,122,359 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica |
10,630 | | $60.28 | 02/27/2018 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
13,648 | | $50.37 | 02/25/2020 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
11,977 | | $62.64 | 02/24/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
5,913 | | $63.42 | 08/11/2021 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
11,503 | | $73.35 | 02/23/2022 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
18,053 | | $85.39 | 02/28/2023 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
15,645 | 7,824 | $96.76 | 02/27/2024 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
8,782 | 17,568 | $114.78 | 02/26/2025 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 26,605 | $118.39 | 02/25/2026 | 25,395 | $3,355,187 | 40,208 | $5,312,281 |
1 | Based on the closing market price of our Common Shares on December 31, 2016 of $132.12 per share. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 103
Executive Compensation Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year End
Contingent on continued employment and, in some circumstances, satisfaction of specified performance targets, the vesting dates for the awards described in the Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End table are as follows:
Name | Vest Date | Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options Unexercisable |
Number of Shares or Units of Stock That Have Not Vested |
Equity Incentive Plan Awards: Number of Unearned Shares, Units, or Other Rights That Have Not Vested12 |
||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | 2/28/2015 | | | 9,992 | ||||||||||||
2/28/2016 | | | 9,990 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2017 | 33,218 | 4,672 | 14,016 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2017 | 34,262 | 4,819 | 14,457 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2017 | 32,728 | 5,522 | 16,568 | |||||||||||||
2/28/2017 | | 9,992 | 9,990 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2018 | 33,221 | 4,672 | 14,016 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2018 | 34,265 | 4,819 | 14,457 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2018 | | 5,524 | 16,569 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2019 | 33,223 | 4,672 | 14,016 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2019 | | 4,819 | 14,458 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2020 | | 4,672 | 47,804 | |||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft | 2/28/2015 | | | 1,322 | ||||||||||||
2/28/2016 | | | 1,322 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2017 | 6,825 | 1,920 | 4,032 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2017 | 6,242 | 1,757 | 1,757 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2017 | 5,744 | 1,938 | 1,938 | |||||||||||||
2/28/2017 | | 2,686 | 1,322 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2018 | 6,828 | 1,920 | 4,032 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2018 | 6,245 | 1,755 | 1,755 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2018 | | 1,938 | 1,938 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2019 | 6,828 | 1,920 | 4,032 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2019 | | 1,757 | 1,757 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2020 | | 1,921 | 4,032 | |||||||||||||
John W. Keogh | 2/28/2015 | | | 2,203 | ||||||||||||
2/28/2016 | | | 2,202 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2017 | 11,540 | 2,206 | 4,285 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2017 | 11,367 | 2,175 | 4,221 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2017 | 10,381 | 2,382 | 4,623 | |||||||||||||
2/28/2017 | | 4,473 | 2,202 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2018 | 11,543 | 2,209 | 4,286 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2018 | 11,370 | 2,175 | 4,221 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2018 | | 2,382 | 4,623 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2019 | 11,545 | 2,207 | 4,285 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2019 | | 2,175 | 4,221 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2020 | | 2,209 | 22,024 | |||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump | 2/26/2017 | | 29,050 | | ||||||||||||
3/1/2017 | | | 2,123 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2018 | | 26,875 | | |||||||||||||
3/1/2018 | | | 2,124 | |||||||||||||
12/17/2018 | | 20,538 | | |||||||||||||
3/1/2019 | | | 2,124 | |||||||||||||
3/1/2020 | | | 2,124 |
104 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year End
Name | Vest Date | Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options Unexercisable |
Number of Shares or Units of Stock That Have Not Vested |
Equity Incentive Plan Awards: Number of Unearned Shares, Units, or Other Rights That Have Not Vested12 |
||||||||||||
John J. Lupica | 2/28/2015 | | | 1,340 | ||||||||||||
2/28/2016 | | | 1,340 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2017 | 8,867 | 2,493 | 5,873 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2017 | 8,784 | 2,471 | 2,471 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2017 | 7,824 | 2,640 | 2,641 | |||||||||||||
2/28/2017 | | 2,723 | 1,341 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2018 | 8,868 | 2,495 | 5,873 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2018 | 8,784 | 2,471 | 2,471 | |||||||||||||
2/27/2018 | | 2,641 | 2,640 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2019 | 8,870 | 2,495 | 5,873 | |||||||||||||
2/26/2019 | | 2,471 | 2,471 | |||||||||||||
2/25/2020 | | 2,495 | 5,874 |
1 | The vesting date for the securities specified in this column is the later of (a) the Vest Date specified for such securities in this table and (b) the date when the Compensation Committee formally confirms vesting pursuant to the process further described in Compensation Discussion & AnalysisPerformance-Based Restricted Stock Vesting. For additional information on performance measures, see footnote 2 to the Grant of Plan-Based Awards table. |
2 | The quarterly vest of the 2013 Performance-Based Restricted Stock grants did not vest in 2015 and 2016 as the performance-based criteria was not met. These shares may vest in 2017 if the performance-based criteria is met. |
Option Exercises and Stock Vested
The following table sets forth information concerning option exercises by, and vesting of restricted stock awards of, our NEOs during 2016.
Option Awards | Stock Awards | |||||||||||||||||||
Name | Number of Shares Acquired on Exercise |
Value Realized on Exercise1 |
Number of Shares Acquired on Vesting2 |
Value Realized on Vesting3 |
||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | 134,000 | $10,295,918 | 128,931 | $15,848,457 | ||||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft | 90,196 | $6,583,963 | 21,823 | $2,650,363 | ||||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh | 61,367 | $4,516,469 | 37,923 | $4,625,323 | ||||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump | | | 9,095 | $1,077,051 | ||||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica | | | 23,156 | $2,812,376 |
1 | The value of an option is the difference between (a) the fair market value of one of our Common Shares on the exercise date and (b) the exercise price of the option. |
2 | Of Common Shares acquired on vesting, the following numbers were respectively acquired due to vesting of performance-based restricted stock target awards on May 19, 2016: Mr. Greenberg (69,301 shares), Mr. Bancroft (8,581 shares), Mr. Keogh (18,107 shares) and Mr. Lupica (10,027). The annual installment of the performance-based restricted stock awards granted in February 2012, 2014 and 2015 vested. |
Of shares acquired on vesting, the following numbers were respectively acquired due to vesting of performance-based restricted stock premium awards: Mr. Greenberg (28,441 shares), Mr. Bancroft (3,867 shares), Mr. Keogh (6,078 shares) and Mr. Lupica (2,984). In May 2016, target awards granted to NEOs in February 2012 earned a Premium Award of 65.50 percent based on cumulative performance below the 75th Percentile. |
For information on performance targets and vesting, see Compensation Discussion & AnalysisPerformance-Based Restricted Stock Vesting. |
3 | The value of a share of restricted stock upon vesting is the fair market value of one of our Common Shares on the vesting date. If vesting occurs on a day on which the New York Stock Exchange is closed, the value realized on vesting is based on the closing price on the open market day prior to the vesting date. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 105
Executive Compensation Pension Benefits
The only pension plans maintained by the Company in which an NEO participates were assumed from Chubb Corp. in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition, the Pension Plan of The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp. Pension Plan) and the Pension Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation (Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan). Mr. Krump is the only NEO that participates in these plans.
The following table sets forth information about participation by Mr. Krump in our pension plans as of December 31, 2016.
Name | Plan Name | Number of Years Credited Service |
Present Value of Accumulated Benefit12 |
Payments During Last Fiscal Year |
||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
Chubb Corp. Pension Plan | 34 | $1,646,417 | | ||||||||||
Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan | 34 | $12,432,844 | |
1 | Represents the present value of the NEOs accumulated pension benefit computed as of the same pension plan measurement date we used for 2016 financial statement reporting. The following actuarial assumptions were used: |
| Interest discount rates: 4.17% (Chubb Corp. Pension Plan); 3.32% (Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan); |
| Future interest crediting rate on cash balance accounts: 4.10%; |
| Mortality table: RP2014 projected using scale MP2016 white collar; and |
| Payment Form: |
| Chubb Corp. Pension Plan 50% take cash balance account as a lump sum (or, for participants hired on or after January 1, 2001, 100% take lump sum) |
| Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan 100% take benefit as a lump sum. |
2 | The figures shown in the table above assume retirement benefits commence at the earliest unreduced retirement age, reflecting the assumptions described in the preceding footnote. However, if the NEOs employment terminated or he retired on December 31, 2016, and plan benefits were immediately payable as a lump sum (calculated using the 5% discount rate specified in the plan), the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan benefit would have been as follows: |
Name | Plan Name | Lump Sum Amount | ||||
Paul J. Krump |
Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan | $12,971,380 |
Chubb Corp. Pension Plan
Employees of Chubb Corp. on the date of its acquisition by the Company were eligible to participate in the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan, a tax-qualified defined benefit plan. Mr. Krump participates in the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan on the same terms and conditions as other eligible employees, except as noted below. The Chubb Corp. Pension Plan, as in effect during 2016, provides each eligible employee with annual retirement income beginning at age 65 equal to the product of:
| the total number of years of participation in the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan; and |
| 1.75 percent of average compensation for the highest five years in the last ten years of participation prior to retirement during which the employee was most highly paid or, if higher, the last 60 consecutive months (final average earnings). |
Average compensation under the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan includes salary and annual non-equity incentive compensation. A social security offset is subtracted from this benefit. The social security offset is equal to the product of:
| the total number of years of participation in the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan; and |
| an amount related to the participants primary social security benefit. |
Benefits can commence as early as age 55. However, if pension benefits commence prior to age 65, they may be actuarially reduced. The reduction in the gross benefit (prior to offset for social security benefits) is based on the participants age at retirement and years of Chubb Corp. Pension Plan participation as follows:
| If the participant has at least 25 years of Chubb Corp. Pension Plan participation, benefits are unreduced at age 62 (Mr. Krump has more than 25 years of Chubb Corp. Pension Plan participation). They are reduced 2.5 percent per year from 62 to 60 (5 percent reduction at 60) and 5 percent per year from 60 to 55 (30 percent reduction at 55). |
| If the participant has at least 15 but less than 25 years of Chubb Corp. Pension Plan participation, benefits are unreduced at age 65. They are reduced 2 percent per year from 65 to 62 (6 percent reduction at 62) and 4 percent per year from 62 to 61 (10 percent reduction at 61) and 5 percent per year from 61 to 55 (40 percent reduction at 55). |
| If the participant has less than 15 years of Chubb Corp. Pension Plan participation, benefits are unreduced at age 65. They are reduced 6.67 percent per year from 65 to 60 (33.3 percent reduction at 60) and 3.33% per year from 60 to 55 (50 percent reduction at 55). |
The participants social security benefit is reduced based on factors relating to the participants year of birth and age at retirement.
Benefits are generally paid in the form of an annuity. If a participant retires and elects a joint and survivor annuity, the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan provides a 10 percent subsidy. The portion of the benefit attributable to the cash balance account, as described in the following paragraph, may be paid in the form of a lump sum upon termination of employment.
106 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Pension Benefits
Effective January 1, 2001, the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan was amended to provide a cash balance benefit, in lieu of the benefit described above, to reduce the rate of increase in the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan costs. This benefit provides for a participant to receive a credit to his or her cash balance account every six months. The amount of the cash balance credit increases from 2.5 percent to 5 percent of compensation as the sum of a participants age and years of service credit increases. The maximum credit of 5 percent of compensation (subject to the maximum limitation on compensation permitted by the Internal Revenue Code) earned over the preceding six months is made when the sum of a participants age and years of service credit equals or exceeds 55 (which is the case for Mr. Krump). Amounts credited to a participants cash balance account earn interest at a rate based on the 30-year U.S. treasury bond rate, subject to a minimum interest rate of 4 percent. Participants who were hired by Chubb Corp. prior to January 1, 2001 (including Mr. Krump) will receive a benefit under the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan equal to the greater of the pension benefit described in the preceding paragraphs or the amount calculated under the cash balance formula.
ERISA and the Internal Revenue Code impose maximum limitations on the recognized compensation and the amount of a pension which may be paid under a funded defined benefit plan such as the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan. The Chubb Corp. Pension Plan complies with these limitations.
In 2016 the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan was amended to freeze further benefit accruals effective as of December 31, 2019.
Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan
The Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan is a supplemental, nonqualified, unfunded plan assumed by the Company in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition. The Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan uses essentially the same benefit formula, early retirement reduction factors and other features as the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan, except that the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan recognizes compensation (salary and annual non-equity incentive plan compensation) above IRS compensation limits. The Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan also recognizes deferred compensation for purposes of determining applicable retirement benefits. Benefits under both the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan and the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan are provided by us on a noncontributory basis.
Benefits payable under the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan are generally paid in the form of a lump sum, calculated using an interest discount rate of 5 percent. However, the portion of the benefit that was earned and vested as of December 31, 2004 may be payable in certain other forms, including installment payments and life annuities, if properly elected by the participant and if the participant satisfies the requirements of the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan.
With the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan freeze in accruals, the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan accruals will also freeze effective December 31, 2019.
Nonqualified Deferred Compensation
The following table sets forth information about nonqualified deferred compensation of our NEOs.
Executive Contributions in Last FY |
Registrant Contributions in Last FY1 |
Aggregate Earnings in Last FY2 |
Aggregate Withdrawals/ Distributions |
Aggregate Balance at Last FYE3 |
||||||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg | $782,000 | $933,300 | $697,576 | | $18,684,570 | |||||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft | $193,875 | $227,550 | $272,987 | | $6,106,691 | |||||||||||||||
John W. Keogh | $319,111 | $377,189 | $265,974 | | $5,320,773 | |||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump4 | | $89,972 | $343,629 | 316,998 | $3,687,827 | |||||||||||||||
John J. Lupica | $246,852 | $290,811 | $468,622 | | $7,504,690 |
1 | The amounts shown in this column are also included in the Summary Compensation Table for 2016 in the All Other Compensation column. |
2 | The Aggregate Earnings for Messrs. Greenberg, Bancroft, Keogh and Lupica resulted from Deferred Compensation Earnings only. The following table reflects the components for the Aggregate Earnings in Last Fiscal Year column for Mr. Krump: |
Name |
CCAP Excess Earnings ($) |
Deferred ($) |
Appreciation and Dividends on Deferred RSUs ($) |
ESOP Excess Earnings |
Total ($) |
|||||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
23,769 | 84,087 | 220,568 | 15,205 | 343,629 |
3 | Of the totals shown in this column, the following amounts are also included in the Summary Compensation Table for 2016, 2015 and 2014: Evan G. Greenberg ($2,728,685), Philip V. Bancroft ($628,350), John W. Keogh ($1,055,852), Paul J. Krump ($89,972) and John J. Lupica ($807,749). For Mr. Krump, this represents the Company match for the CCAP Excess Benefit Plan. |
4 | This table does not include amounts under the Chubb Corp. Pension Excess Benefit Plan, which appear in the Pension Benefits table on page 106. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 107
Executive Compensation Nonqualified Deferred Compensation
Chubb Limited and Chubb INA Holdings Inc. (formerly ACE INA Holdings Inc.) sponsor a total of seven nonqualified deferred compensation plans in which the NEOs participate. All of these plansThe ACE Limited Supplemental Retirement Plan, The ACE Limited Elective Deferred Compensation Plan, The Chubb US Supplemental Retirement Plan, The Chubb US Deferred Compensation Plan, the Pension Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation, the Defined Contribution Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation, and The Chubb Corporation Key Employee Deferred Compensation Planare unfunded nonqualified plans designed to benefit employees who are highly compensated or part of a select group of management. Following the Chubb Corp. acquisition in January 2016, Chubb INA Holdings Inc. became the plan sponsor of the three Chubb Corp. nonqualified plansThe Pension Excess Benefit Plan of the Chubb Corporation, The Defined Contribution Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation, and The Chubb Corporation Key Employee Deferred Compensation Plan. Mr. Krump is the only NEO who is a participant in these three plans.
Chubb Limited and Chubb INA Holdings Inc. set aside assets in rabbi trusts to fund the obligations under the above seven plans. The funding (inclusive of investment returns) of the rabbi trusts attempts to mirror the participants hypothetical earnings under each plan, where relevant.
Participants in the ACE Limited Supplemental Retirement Plan contributed (until 2009) and Chubb US Supplemental Retirement Plan contribute to such plans only after their contributions to tax-qualified plans are capped under one or more Internal Revenue Code provisions. Participants in the ACE Limited Elective Deferred Compensation Plan were allowed to defer (until 2009) and Chubb US Deferred Compensation Plans may defer additional amounts of salary or bonuses with deferred amounts credited to these plans. Up to 50 percent of salary and up to 100 percent of cash bonuses are eligible for deferral under the Chubb US Deferred Compensation Plan, while the ACE Limited Elective Deferred Compensation Plan permitted deferral of up to 100 percent of salary, minus payroll taxes and other payroll obligations, and up to 100 percent of cash bonuses. NEOs are not treated differently from other participants under these plans. Effective January 1, 2009, participation under the ACE Limited nonqualified plans ceased on compensation paid for 2009 performance, due to the impact of Code section 457A. Starting in 2009, certain Bermuda-based employees, among them NEOs, participate under the Chubb INA Holdings Inc. nonqualified plans. In 2011, the ACE Limited nonqualified plans (not including the ACE Bermuda Employee Retirement Plan) were amended to provide that distributions would be paid no later than 2017 to comply with limitations imposed by Internal Revenue Code Section 457A and related legislation, and such distributions are to be made in April 2017.
For more information on our nonqualified deferred compensation plans, see the section of this proxy statement titled Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in ControlNon-Qualified Retirement Plans and Deferred Compensation Plans.
108 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
The table below contains estimates of potential payments to each of our NEOs upon termination of employment or a change in control under current employment arrangements and other compensation programs, assuming the termination or change of control event occurred on December 31, 2016. Pursuant to our Articles of Association, in 2015 we entered into non-compete agreements with our Executive Management and terminated our Severance Plan with respect to Executive Management. Following the table we have provided a brief description of such employment arrangements and other compensation programs, including the non-compete agreements.
Name | Cash Severance | Medical Continuation1 | Retirement Plan Continuation |
Value of Accelerated & Continued Equity and Performance Awards2 |
||||||||||||
Evan G. Greenberg |
||||||||||||||||
Separation without cause |
$16,000,000 | $42,800 | | $24,406,836 | ||||||||||||
Change in control |
| | | $36,812,053 | ||||||||||||
Separation for cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Retirement |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Death or disability |
| | | $36,812,053 | ||||||||||||
Philip V. Bancroft |
||||||||||||||||
Separation without cause |
$4,203,333 | $68,797 | | $5,010,913 | ||||||||||||
Change in control |
| | | $7,141,819 | ||||||||||||
Separation for cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Retirement |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Death or disability |
| | | $7,141,819 | ||||||||||||
John W. Keogh |
||||||||||||||||
Separation without cause |
$6,700,000 | $33,296 | | $7,798,942 | ||||||||||||
Change in control |
| | | $12,861,881 | ||||||||||||
Separation for cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Retirement |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Death or disability |
| | | $12,861,881 | ||||||||||||
Paul J. Krump |
||||||||||||||||
Separation without cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Change in control |
| | | $11,224,651 | ||||||||||||
Separation for cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Retirement |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Death or disability |
| | | $11,224,651 | ||||||||||||
John J. Lupica |
||||||||||||||||
Separation without cause |
$5,290,000 | $35,853 | | $6,628,027 | ||||||||||||
Change in control |
| | | $9,614,041 | ||||||||||||
Separation for cause |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Retirement |
| | | | ||||||||||||
Death or disability |
| | | $9,614,041 |
1 | The value of medical continuation benefits is based on the medical insurance premium rates payable by the Company and applicable to the NEOs as of year-end 2016. |
2 | Based on the closing market price of our Common Shares on December 31, 2016 of $132.12 per share. |
The table above does not duplicate aggregate balance amounts disclosed in the sections of this proxy statement titled Executive CompensationNonqualified Deferred Compensation and Pension Benefits including amounts that may become payable on an accelerated timeline due to termination of employment or a change in control as described below under Non-Qualified Retirement Plans and Deferred Compensation Plans and Pension Benefits.
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 109
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
The ACE Limited Supplemental Retirement Plan
This is a non-qualified retirement plan for higher-paid employees who are United States citizens or permanent residents.
Effective January 1, 2009, contributions ceased for services performed in 2009 or later.
In 2011, the plan was amended so distributions would be paid no later than 2017 to comply with limitations imposed by Internal Revenue Code Section 457A and related legislation, and such distributions are to be made in April 2017.
|
Contributions to this plan are made where Internal Revenue Code provisions limit the amount of contributions that employees may make or Chubb makes on their behalf to the qualified ACE Limited Employee Retirement Plan.
Contributions credited to this supplemental plan mirror the employee contributions, employer matching contributions, and a non-contributory six percent employer contribution that would have been made under the ACE Limited Employee Retirement Plan had the Internal Revenue Code provisions not limited the contributions.
Vesting: Upon completion of one year of service.
Distributions: Following the year the participant has terminated employment and participants attained age 55. However, for participants employed by a Chubb company on or after 2007, distributions will be made in the year following termination of employment, regardless of the participants age. |
110 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
The Chubb US Supplemental Retirement Plan
This is a non-qualified retirement plan for a select group of employees who are generally higher paid.
Beginning in 2009, Bermuda-based employees who are also employed by a United States employer participate in the Plan. |
Contributions to this plan are made where Internal Revenue Code provisions limit the contributions of these employees under one or both U.S. qualified plans: the ACE USA Employee Retirement 401(k) Plan (formerly known as the ACE USA Employee Retirement Savings Plan) and the ACE USA Basic Employee Retirement Savings Plan.
Contributions credited to this supplemental plan mirror the employee contributions and employer matching contributions that would have been made under the ACE USA Employee Retirement 401(k) Plan and the non-discretionary six percent (for NEOs) employer contribution that would have been made under the ACE USA Basic Employee Retirement Savings Plan but for the limits imposed by the Internal Revenue Code.
Vesting: Upon completion of two years of service, a participant vests in the employer contributions under this supplemental plan.
Distributions: After termination of employment, regardless of age or reason for termination. Distributions are generally made in January of the year following the participants termination of employment, subject to restrictions imposed by Internal Revenue Code Section 409A.
Chubb makes employer contributions once each year for participants employed on December 31.
| |
The Chubb US Deferred Compensation Plan
This is a non-qualified deferred compensation plan for a select group of employees who are generally higher paid that permits them to defer the receipt of a portion of their compensation. |
The plan also credits employer contributions that would have been made or credited to the ACE USA Employee Retirement 401(k) Plan, the ACE USA Basic Employee Retirement Savings Plan, or the ACE USA Supplemental Employee Retirement Plan if the employee had received the compensation rather than electing to defer it, subject to the same vesting period as those plans.
Participants generally elect the time and form of payment at the same time that they elect to defer compensation. Participants may elect:
to receive distributions at a specified date or at termination of employment;
to receive distributions in the form of a lump sum or periodic payments;
a different distribution date and form of payment each time they elect to defer compensation. The new date and payment form will apply to the compensation that is the subject of the new deferral election.
For plan amounts subject to Internal Revenue Code Section 409A, the plan imposes additional requirements on the time and form of payments.
Chubb makes employer contributions once each year for participants employed on December 31.
| |
The ACE Limited Elective Deferred Compensation Plan
This is a deferred compensation plan for employees who are United States citizens or permanent residents that permits them to defer the receipt of a portion of their compensation.
Effective January 1, 2009, contributions ceased for services performed in 2009 or later.
|
The plan also credits contributions that would have been made to the ACE Limited Employee Retirement Plan, the ACE Limited Supplemental Retirement Plan or the ACE Limited Bermudian National Pension Plan if the employee had received the compensation rather than electing to defer it, subject to the same vesting period as those plans.
Distribution: Participants generally receive distribution of their plan account balance in a lump sum upon termination of employment.
Participants may instead elect to receive distributions at a specified date while still employed or at termination of employment, and they may elect whether they want to receive a lump sum or periodic payments.
continues on next page |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 111
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
The ACE Limited Elective (continued)
In 2011, the plan was amended so distributions would be paid no later than 2017 to comply with in April 2017. |
Participants make the election regarding form and time of payment at the same time that they elect to defer compensation.
Participants may elect a different distribution date and payment form each time they elect to defer compensation, and the new date and payment form will apply to the compensation that is the subject of the new deferral election.
Death, Disability or Change in Control Payments under the ACE Limited Elective Deferred Compensation Plan
Distribution upon death or disability: a lump sum payment upon the participants death or disability, as defined under the plan, overriding any other election made under the plan.
Distribution upon change in control: For plan amounts subject to Internal Revenue Code Section 409A, the plan requires distributions to be made upon a change in control regardless of the participants distribution elections or whether the participants employment has terminated. Under the plan, a change in control occurs when a majority of the members of our Board of Directors is replaced during any 12-month period by directors whose appointment or election is not endorsed by a majority of the members of our Board of Directors prior to the date of the appointment or election.
In addition, a change in control occurs when any of the following events occurs with respect to a Chubb company which employs the participant, is obligated to make plan payments to the participant, or is either the majority shareholder or is in a chain of corporations comprising the majority shareholder of the Chubb company:
any one person (or more than one person acting as a group) acquires stock ownership of the corporation that, together with stock held by such person or group, constitutes more than 50 percent of the total fair market value or total voting power of the stock of such corporation;
any one person (or more than one person acting as a group) acquires, or has acquired, stock ownership of the corporation representing 35 percent or more of the total voting power of the stock of such corporation during the 12-month period ending on the date of the most recent acquisition by such person or persons; or
any one person (or more than one person acting as a group) acquires, or has acquired, assets from the corporation that have a total gross fair market value equal to or more than 40 percent of the total gross fair market value of all of the assets of the corporation immediately prior to such acquisition or acquisitions during the 12-month period ending on the date of the most recent acquisition by such person or persons. For this purpose, gross fair market value means the value of the assets of the corporation, or the value of the assets being disposed of, determined without regard to any liabilities associated with such assets.
| |||
The Pension Excess Benefit Plan
This plan is a supplemental, nonqualified, unfunded plan similar to the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan but recognizes compensation above IRS compensation limits.
Plan accruals will freeze effective December 31, 2019, when the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan benefits freeze.
|
The plans benefits are calculated in the same fashion as the Chubb Corp. Pension Plan benefits in excess of IRS limits.
The plan benefits are generally paid in a lump sum using an interest rate of 5 percent.
Additional distribution options are permitted for benefits accrued prior to 2005. |
112 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
The Defined Contribution Excess Benefit Plan of The Chubb Corporation (assumed in
connection with the Chubb
This is a non-qualified deferred compensation plan for a select group of employees who are generally higher paid that permits them to defer the receipt of a portion of their compensation.
Amounts credited for service in 2016 and later are paid in cash (not deferred).
For additional information on this plan, see Pension Benefits beginning on page 106.
|
The plan provides a 4 percent contribution above the IRS qualified plan limits.
Prior to the Chubb Corp. acquisition, participants could choose to defer these amounts or receive them in cash.
Deferrals are notionally invested in the Fidelity Stable Value Fund.
In 2004, The Chubb Corporation Employee Stock Ownership Excess Benefit Plan was merged with the plan.
Earnings on The Chubb Corporation Employee Stock Ownership Plan shares are based on the change in Common Shares and dividends paid. | |||
The Chubb Corporation Key Employee Deferred Compensation Plan (assumed in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition)
This is a non-qualified deferred compensation plan for a select group of employees who are generally higher paid that permits them to defer the receipt of a portion of their compensation.
The last deferral election offered was for the 2016 bonuses (payable in 2017).
|
The plan permitted deferrals of salary, bonus and stock awards.
Our acquisition of Chubb Corp. was a distributable event (where chosen) and Mr. Krump received a distribution from the plan.
The plan contains an older plan, The Chubb Corporation Executive Deferred Compensation Plan, which is not subject to Internal Revenue Code section 409A. Mr. Krump has deferrals under both pre-409A and 409A plans. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 113
Executive Compensation Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control
114 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 115
Audit Committee Report
116 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Audit Committee Report
The foregoing report has been approved by all members of the Audit Committee.
![]() |
|
|||
Michael G. Atieh, Chair | Theodore E. Shasta |
|||
![]() |
|
|||
James I. Cash | David H. Sidwell |
|||
![]() |
||||
Kimberly A. Ross |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 117
118 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 119
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
120 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 121
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
122 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
Organizational Matters Required by Swiss Law
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 123
Information About the Annual General Meeting and Voting
Shareholder Submitted Agenda Items for 2018 Annual General Meeting
124 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Our Board of Directors does not know of any matters that may be presented at the Annual General Meeting other than those specifically set forth in the notice of Annual General Meeting. If any other matters come before the meeting or any adjournment thereof, the persons named in the accompanying form of proxy and acting thereunder will vote in accordance with their best judgment with respect to such matters.
You may request a copy of any of our proxy materials, at no cost, by contacting Investor Relations via telephone or email at:
Telephone+1 (441) 299-9283; or
E-mailinvestorrelations@chubb.com
You may also contact Investor Relations by mail at:
Investor Relations
Chubb Limited
17 Woodbourne Avenue
Hamilton, HM08
Bermuda
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 125
In presenting our results for purposes of our compensation determinations, we included and discussed certain non-GAAP financial measures. The below non-GAAP measures, which may be defined differently by other companies, are important for an understanding of our overall results of operations and financial condition. However, they should not be viewed as a substitute for measures determined in accordance with U.S. GAAP. Amounts below are shown in millions of U.S. dollars, except for percentages, share and per share data.
Operating income is a non-GAAP financial measure which excludes adjusted realized gains and losses, Chubb integration and related expenses, amortization of purchase accounting fair value adjustments of acquired invested assets and long-term debt in connection with the Chubb Corp. acquisition. We believe this presentation enhances the understanding of our results of operations by highlighting the underlying profitability of our insurance business. We exclude adjusted net realized gains (losses) and net realized gains (losses) included in other income (expense) related to partially-owned entities, because the amount of these gains (losses) is heavily influenced by, and fluctuates in part according to, the availability of market opportunities. We also exclude Chubb integration and related expenses related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition due to the size and complexity of this acquisition. These integration and related expenses are distortive to our results and are not indicative of our underlying profitability. We believe that excluding these integration and related expenses facilitates the comparison of our financial results to our historical operating results. Operating income should not be viewed as a substitute for net income determined in accordance with GAAP. The following table presents the reconciliation of Net income to Operating income:
(in millions of U.S. dollars, except shares and per share data) | 2016 | 2015 | ||||||||
Net income | $4,135 | $2,834 | ||||||||
Amortization of fair value adjustment of acquired invested assets and long-term debt, pre-tax1 | (345 | ) | | |||||||
Tax benefit on amortization adjustment |
101 | | ||||||||
Chubb integration and related expenses, pre-tax | (499 | ) | (62 | ) | ||||||
Tax benefit on Chubb integration and related expenses |
143 | 20 | ||||||||
Adjusted net realized gains (losses)2 | (140 | ) | (411 | ) | ||||||
Net realized gains (losses) related to unconsolidated entities | 227 | 67 | ||||||||
Tax (expense) benefit on adjusted net realized gains (losses) |
(68 | ) | 10 | |||||||
Operating income |
$4,716 | $3,210 | ||||||||
Denominator |
465,949,399 | 328,835,378 | ||||||||
Diluted earnings per share | ||||||||||
Net income |
$8.87 | $8.62 | ||||||||
Amortization of fair value adjustment of acquired invested asset and long-term debt, net of tax |
(0.52 | ) | | |||||||
Chubb integration and related expenses, net of tax |
(0.76 | ) | (0.13 | ) | ||||||
Adjusted net realized gains (losses), net of tax |
0.03 | (1.01 | ) | |||||||
Operating income |
$10.12 | $9.76 |
1 | Related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition. |
2 | Adjusted net realized gains (losses) exclude realized losses on crop derivatives of $5 million and $9 million for 2016 and 2015, respectively. |
126 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Operating return on equity (ROE) or ROE calculated using operating income: The ROE denominator includes the average shareholders equity for the period adjusted to exclude unrealized gains (losses) on investments, net of tax. In addition, the denominator was adjusted to account for the weighted-average impact of the $15,527 million issuance of common shares and equity awards related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition on January 14, 2016. Operating ROE is a useful measure as it enhances the understanding of the return on shareholders equity by highlighting the underlying profitability relative to shareholders equity excluding the effect of unrealized gains and losses on our investments.
(in millions of U.S. dollars, except ratios) | 2016 | 2015 | ||||||||
Net income |
$4,135 | $2,834 | ||||||||
Operating income |
$4,716 | $3,210 | ||||||||
Equitybeginning of period, as reported | $29,135 | $29,587 | ||||||||
Add: weighted average impact of equity issuance (351 days) | 14,931 | | ||||||||
Less: unrealized gains (losses) on investments, net of deferred tax | 874 | 1,851 | ||||||||
Equitybeginning of period, as adjusted | $43,192 | $27,736 | ||||||||
Equityend of period, as reported | $48,275 | $29,135 | ||||||||
Less: weighted average impact of equity issuance (14 days) | 596 | | ||||||||
Less: unrealized gains (losses) on investments, net of deferred tax | 1,058 | 874 | ||||||||
Equityend of period, as adjusted |
$46,621 | $28,261 | ||||||||
Weighted average equity, as reported |
$45,873 | $29,361 | ||||||||
Weighted average equity, as adjusted |
$44,907 | $27,999 | ||||||||
Operating ROE |
10.5% | 11.5% | ||||||||
ROE |
9.0% | 9.7% |
P&C combined ratio includes the impact of realized gains and losses on crop derivatives. These derivatives were purchased to provide economic benefit, in a manner similar to reinsurance protection, in the event that a significant decline in commodity pricing will impact underwriting results. We view gains and losses on these derivatives as part of the results of our underwriting operations. The P&C combined ratio also excludes the one-time pension curtailment benefit of $113 million recognized in 2016. We believe that excluding the impact of the one-time pension curtailment provides a better evaluation of our underwriting performance and enhances the understanding of the trends in our property & casualty business that may be obscured by this item. In addition, the 2016 As If P&C combined ratio excludes purchase accounting adjustments related to the Chubb Corp. acquisition as shown below. The 2015 As If P&C combined ratio is Legacy ACE plus Legacy Chubb historical combined ratio including certain reclassification of certain income and expense items in the 2015 reported amounts of Legacy Chubb to be on the same basis as Legacy ACE results.
The following tables present the reconciliation of combined ratio to P&C and As If P&C combined ratio:
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement 127
Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Tangible book value per common share is shareholders equity less goodwill and other intangible assets, net of tax, divided by the shares outstanding. We believe that goodwill and other intangible assets are not indicative of our underlying insurance results or trends and make book value comparisons to less acquisitive peer companies less meaningful.
The following table provides a reconciliation of tangible book value per share:
December 31, 2016 | December 31, 2015 | |||||||||
Shareholders equity | $48,275 | $29,135 | ||||||||
Less: goodwill and other intangible assets, net of tax | 20,019 | 5,683 | ||||||||
Numerator for tangible book value per share | $28,256 | $23,452 | ||||||||
Shares outstanding | 465,968,716 | 324,563,441 | ||||||||
Book value per common share | $103.60 | $89.77 | ||||||||
Tangible book value per common share | $60.64 | $72.25 |
128 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Table of |
Page | |||||||
SECTION 1. GENERAL | A-2 | |||||||
1.1. |
Purpose |
A-2 | ||||||
1.2. |
Operation and Administration |
A-2 | ||||||
SECTION 2. METHOD OF PURCHASE |
|
A-2 |
| |||||
2.1. |
Eligibility |
A-2 | ||||||
2.2. |
Participation Election |
A-2 | ||||||
2.3. |
Purchase of Stock |
A-3 | ||||||
2.4. |
Termination of Participation |
A-3 | ||||||
SECTION 3. OPERATION AND ADMINISTRATION |
|
A-3 |
| |||||
3.1. |
Effective Date |
A-3 | ||||||
3.2. |
Shares Subject to Plan |
A-3 | ||||||
3.3. |
Adjustments to Shares |
A-3 | ||||||
3.4. |
Limit on Distribution |
A-4 | ||||||
3.5. |
Withholding |
A-4 | ||||||
3.6. |
Transferability |
A-4 | ||||||
3.7. |
Limitation of Implied Rights |
A-4 | ||||||
3.8. |
Evidence |
A-4 | ||||||
3.9. |
Action by Employers |
A-4 | ||||||
3.10. |
Gender and Number |
A-4 | ||||||
SECTION 4. COMMITTEE |
|
A-4 |
| |||||
4.1. |
Administration |
A-4 | ||||||
4.2. |
Selection of Committee |
A-4 | ||||||
4.3. |
Powers of Committee |
A-4 | ||||||
4.4. |
Delegation by Committee |
A-5 | ||||||
4.5. |
Information to be Furnished to Committee |
A-5 | ||||||
4.6. |
Liability and Indemnification of Committee |
A-5 | ||||||
SECTION 5. AMENDMENT AND TERMINATION |
|
A-5 |
| |||||
SECTION 6. DEFINED TERMS |
|
A-5 |
|
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement A-1
Annex A Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan
Chubb Limited
Employee Stock Purchase Plan
Section 1.
General
1.1. Purpose. The Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan (the Plan), amended and restated effective as of February 23, 2017, has been established by Chubb Limited (the Company) to provide eligible employees of the Company and the Related Companies with an opportunity to acquire a proprietary interest in the Company through the purchase of common shares of the Company (Stock). The Plan is intended to qualify as an employee stock purchase plan under section 423 of the Code, and the provisions of the Plan are to be construed in a manner consistent with the requirements of that section.
1.2. Operation and Administration. The operation and administration of the Plan shall be subject to the provisions of Section 3. Capitalized terms in the Plan shall be defined as set forth in Section 6 or elsewhere in the Plan.
1.3. History. The Plan was first adopted by the Board on July 28, 1995, as the ACE Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan, which was subsequently amended through the fourth amendment thereof. Subject to the approval of the shareholders of the Company at the Companys 2017 annual meeting of its shareholders, an amendment and restatement of the Plan was adopted by the Board of Directors effective as of February 23, 2017. The name of the Plan was changed to the Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan as part of the amendment and restatement.
Section 2.
Method of Purchase
2.1. Eligibility. Plan participation shall be available to (and shall be limited to) all persons who are employees of the Employers, except that the following persons shall not be eligible to participate in the Plan:
(a) | An employee who has been employed less than 500 hours and less than six months. |
(b) | An employee whose customary employment is 20 hours or less per week. |
(c) | An employee whose customary employment is for not more than five months in any calendar year. |
(d) | An employee who owns, or who would own upon the exercise of any rights extended under the Plan and the exercise of any other option held by the employee (whether qualified or non-qualified), shares possessing 5% or more of the total combined voting power or value of all classes of stock of the Company or of any parent or subsidiary corporation. |
(e) | An employee who is a citizen or resident of a foreign jurisdiction (without regard to whether they are also citizens of the United States or resident aliens (within the meaning of Section 7701(b)(1)(A) of the Code)) with respect to whom either one or both of the following apply: (i) the grant of an option under the Plan or an offering to a citizen or resident of the foreign jurisdiction is prohibited under the laws of such jurisdiction; or (ii) compliance with the laws of the foreign jurisdiction would cause the Plan or offering to violate the requirements of Section 423 of the Code. |
Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this subsection 2.1, an individual may participate in the Plan for any Subscription Period only if he is employed by an Employer on the first day of that period.
2.2. Participation Election. The Committee shall establish Subscription Periods of not longer than one year for the accumulation of funds necessary for payment of the Purchase Price (as defined in subsection 2.3) of Stock under the Plan. For any Subscription Period, an eligible employee shall become a Plan Participant by filing, with the Committee, a written payroll deduction authorization with respect to Compensation otherwise payable to the Participant during the period. Such payroll deductions shall be any full percentage of the Compensation of the Participant, or any specified whole dollar amount, up to but not more than 10% of his Compensation in either case. After the beginning of the Subscription Period, and except as otherwise provided in subsection 2.4, a Participant may not alter the rate of his payroll deductions for that period. Subject to the limitations of subsection 2.3, each eligible employee who has elected to become a Participant for a Subscription Period in accordance with the foregoing provisions of this subsection 2.2 shall be granted on the first day of such Subscription Period an option to purchase (at the applicable Purchase Price) on the Exercise Date (as defined in subsection 2.3) for such Subscription Period up to a number of whole shares of Stock determined by dividing such Participants accumulated payroll deductions as of
A-2 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Annex A Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan
such Exercise Date by the applicable Purchase Price. Exercise of the option shall occur as provided in subsection 2.3, unless the Participant has terminated participation in the Plan prior to the Exercise Date as provided in subsection 2.4 or the Participant elects not to exercise the option as provided in subsection 2.3(b). The option shall expire on the last day of the Subscription Period.
2.3. Purchase of Stock. On the last day of each Subscription Period (the Exercise Date), a Participant shall become eligible to exercise his option to purchase the number of whole shares of Stock as his accumulated payroll deductions for the Subscription Period will purchase, subject to the following:
(a) | The Purchase Price per share shall be equal to 85% of the fair market value of Stock on the Exercise Date; provided, however, that in no event shall the purchase price be less than the par value of the Stock. |
(b) | A Participant shall be deemed to have elected to purchase the shares of Stock which he became entitled to purchase on the Exercise Date unless he shall notify the Committee within seven days following the Exercise Date, or such shorter period as the Committee may establish, that he elects not to make such purchase. |
(c) | Any accumulated payroll deductions that are not used to purchase full shares of Stock under the Plan shall be paid to the Participant without interest. |
(d) | No employee shall have the right to purchase more than $25,000 in value of Stock under the Plan (and any other employee stock purchase plan described in Code section 423 and maintained by the Company or any Related Company) in any calendar year, such value being based on the fair market value of Stock as of the date on which the option to purchase the Stock is granted, as determined in accordance with subsection 2.2 of the Plan. |
2.4. Termination of Participation. A Participant may discontinue his participation in the Plan for any Subscription Period, whereupon all of the Participants payroll deductions for the Subscription Period will be promptly paid to him without interest, and no further payroll deductions will be made from his pay for that period. If a Participants employment with the Employers terminates during a Subscription Period for any reason, all payroll deductions accumulated by the Participant under the Plan for the period shall be paid to the Participant without interest.
Section 3.
Operation and Administration
3.1. Effective Date. Subject to the approval of the shareholders of the Company at the Companys 1996 annual meeting of its shareholders, the Plan shall be effective as of the date on which it is adopted by the Board; provided, however, that to the extent that rights are granted under the Plan prior to its approval by shareholders, they shall be contingent on approval of the Plan by the shareholders of the Company. The Plan shall be unlimited in duration and, in the event of Plan termination, shall remain in effect as long as any rights granted under the Plan are outstanding.
3.2. Shares Subject to Plan. Shares of Stock to be purchased under the Plan shall be subject to the following:
(a) | The shares of Stock which may be purchased under the Plan shall be currently authorized but unissued shares, or shares purchased in the open market by a direct or indirect wholly owned subsidiary of the Company (as determined by any executive officer of the Company). The Company may contribute to the subsidiary an amount sufficient to accomplish the purchase in the open market of the shares of Stock to be so acquired (as determined by any executive officer of the Company). |
(b) | Subject to the provisions of subsection 3.3, an additional 2 million shares of Stock in the aggregate shall be available for purchase under the Plan, which 2 million shares of Stock shall be in addition to any remaining shares of the 4,500,000 shares of Stock designated as available for purchase under the Plan since the Plans original Effective Date. |
(c) | A Participant will have no interest in shares of Stock covered by his Subscription Agreement until the shares are delivered to him. |
3.3. Adjustments to Shares.
(a) | If the Company shall effect any subdivision or consolidation of shares of Stock or other capital readjustment, payment of stock dividend, stock split, combination of shares or recapitalization or other increase or reduction of the number of shares of Stock outstanding without receiving compensation therefor in money, services or property, then, subject to the requirements of Code section 423, the Committee shall adjust the number of shares of Stock available under the Plan. |
(b) | If the Company is reorganized, merged or consolidated or is party to a plan of exchange with another corporation, pursuant to which reorganization, merger, consolidation or plan of exchange the shareholders of the Company receive any shares of stock or other securities or property, or the Company shall distribute securities of another corporation to its shareholders, then, subject to the requirements of Code section 423, there shall be substituted for the shares subject to outstanding rights |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement A-3
Annex A Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan
to purchase Stock under the Plan an appropriate number of shares of each class of stock or amount of other securities or property which were distributed to the shareholders of the Company in respect of such shares. |
3.4. Limit on Distribution. Distribution of shares of Stock or other amounts under the Plan shall be subject to the following:
(a) | Notwithstanding any other provision of the Plan, the Company shall have no liability to issue any shares of Stock under the Plan unless such delivery or distribution would comply with all applicable laws and the applicable requirements of any securities exchange or similar entity. |
(b) | In the case of a Participant who is subject to Section 16(a) and 16(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Committee may, at any time, add such conditions and limitations with respect to such Participant as the Committee, in its sole discretion, deems necessary or desirable to comply with Section 16(a) or 16(b) and the rules and regulations thereunder or to obtain any exemption therefrom. |
(c) | To the extent that the Plan provides for issuance of certificates to reflect the transfer of shares of Stock, the transfer of such shares may, at the direction of the Committee, be effected on a non-certificated basis, to the extent not prohibited by the provisions of Rule 16b-3, applicable local law, the applicable rules of any stock exchange, or any other applicable rules. |
3.5. Withholding. All benefits under the Plan are subject to withholding of all applicable taxes.
3.6. Transferability. Except as otherwise permitted under Code section 424 and SEC Rule 16b-3, neither the amount of any payroll deductions made with respect to a Participants compensation nor any Participants rights to purchase shares of Stock under the Plan may be pledged or hypothecated, nor may they be assigned or transferred other than by will and the laws of descent and distribution. During the lifetime of the Participant, the rights provided to the Participant under the Plan may be exercised only by him.
3.7. Limitation of Implied Rights.
(a) | Neither a Participant nor any other person shall, by reason of the Plan, acquire any right in or title to any assets, funds or property of the Employers whatsoever, including, without limitation, any specific funds, assets, or other property which the Employers, in their sole discretion, may set aside in anticipation of a liability under the Plan. A Participant shall have only a contractual right to the amounts, if any, payable under the Plan, unsecured by any assets of the Employers. Nothing contained in the Plan shall constitute a guarantee by any of the Employers that the assets of the Employers shall be sufficient to pay any benefits to any person. |
(b) | The Plan does not constitute a contract of employment, and participation in the Plan will not give any employee the right to be retained in the employ of an Employer or any Related Company, nor any right or claim to any benefit under the Plan, unless such right or claim has specifically accrued under the terms of the Plan. Except as otherwise provided in the Plan, no right to purchase shares under the Plan shall confer upon the holder thereof any right as a shareholder of the Company prior to the date on which he fulfills all service requirements and other conditions for receipt of such rights. |
3.8. Evidence. Evidence required of anyone under the Plan may be by certificate, affidavit, document or other information which the person acting on it considers pertinent and reliable, and signed, made or presented by the proper party or parties.
3.9. Action by Employers. Any action required or permitted to be taken by any Employer shall be by resolution of its board of directors, or by action of one or more members of the board (including a committee of the board) who are duly authorized to act for the board, or (except to the extent prohibited by the provisions of Rule 16b-3, applicable local law, the applicable rules of any stock exchange, or any other applicable rules) by a duly authorized officer of the Employer.
3.10. Gender and Number. Where the context admits, words in any gender shall include any other gender, words in the singular shall include the plural and the plural shall include the singular.
Section 4.
Committee
4.1. Administration. The authority to control and manage the operation and administration of the Plan shall be vested in a committee (the Committee) in accordance with this Section 4.
4.2. Selection of Committee. The Committee shall be selected by the Board, and shall consist of not less than two members of the Board, or such greater number as may be required for compliance with SEC Rule 16b-3.
4.3. Powers of Committee. The authority to manage and control the operation and administration of the Plan shall be vested in the Committee, subject to the following:
(a) | Subject to the provisions of the Plan, the Committee will have the authority and discretion to establish the terms, conditions, restrictions, and other provisions applicable to the right to purchase shares of Stock under the Plan. |
A-4 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Annex A Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan
(b) | The Committee will have the authority and discretion to interpret the Plan, to establish, amend, and rescind any rules and regulations relating to the Plan, to determine the terms and provisions of any agreements made pursuant to the Plan, and to make all other determinations that may be necessary or advisable for the administration of the Plan. |
(c) | Any interpretation of the Plan by the Committee and any decision made by it under the Plan is final and binding on all persons. |
4.4. Delegation by Committee. Except to the extent prohibited by the provisions of Rule 16b-3, applicable local law, the applicable rules of any stock exchange, or any other applicable rules, the Committee may allocate all or any portion of its responsibilities and powers to any one or more of its members and may delegate all or any part of its responsibilities and powers to any person or persons selected by it. Any such allocation or delegation may be revoked by the Committee at any time.
4.5. Information to be Furnished to Committee. The Employers and Related Companies shall furnish the Committee with such data and information as may be required for it to discharge its duties. The records of the Employers and Related Companies as to an employees or Participants employment, termination of employment, leave of absence, reemployment and compensation shall be conclusive on all persons unless determined to be incorrect. Participants and other persons entitled to benefits under the Plan must furnish the Committee such evidence, data or information as the Committee considers desirable to carry out the terms of the Plan.
4.6. Liability and Indemnification of Committee. No member or authorized delegate of the Committee shall be liable to any person for any action taken or omitted in connection with the administration of the Plan unless attributable to his own fraud or willful misconduct; nor shall the Employers be liable to any person for any such action unless attributable to fraud or willful misconduct on the part of a director or employee of the Employers. The Committee, the individual members thereof, and persons acting as the authorized delegates of the Committee under the Plan, shall be indemnified by the Employers, to the fullest extent permitted by law, against any and all liabilities, losses, costs and expenses (including legal fees and expenses) of whatsoever kind and nature which may be imposed on, incurred by or asserted against the Committee or its members or authorized delegates by reason of the performance of a Committee function if the Committee or its members or authorized delegates did not act dishonestly or in willful violation of the law or regulation under which such liability, loss, cost or expense arises. This indemnification shall not duplicate but may supplement any coverage available under any applicable insurance.
Section 5.
Amendment and Termination
The Board may, at any time, amend or terminate the Plan, provided that, subject to subsection 3.3 (relating to certain adjustments to shares), no amendment or termination may adversely affect the rights of any Participant or beneficiary with respect to shares that have been purchased prior to the date such amendment is adopted by the Board. No amendment of the Plan may be made without approval of the Companys shareholders to the extent that such approval is required to maintain compliance with the requirements of Code section 423.
Section 6.
Defined Terms
For purposes of the Plan, the terms listed below shall be defined as follows:
(a) | Board. The term Board shall mean the Board of Directors of the Company. |
(b) | Code. The term Code means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended. A reference to any provision of the Code shall include reference to any successor provision of the Code. |
(c) | Compensation. The term Compensation means total compensation paid by an Employer for the applicable period specified in Section 2.2, exclusive of any payment in cash or kind under any stock option plan, deferred compensation plan, or other employee benefit plan or program of the Company or Related Company. |
(d) | Dollars. As used in the Plan, the term dollars or numbers preceded by the symbol $ shall mean amounts in United States Dollars. |
(e) | Effective Date. The Effective Date shall be the date on which the Plan is adopted by the Board. |
(f) | Employer. The Company and each Related Company which, with the consent of the Company, adopts the Plan for the benefit of its eligible employees are referred to collectively as the Employers and individually as an Employer. |
Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement A-5
Annex A Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan
(g) | Fair Market Value. The Fair Market Value of a share of Stock of the Company as of any date shall be the closing market composite price for such Stock as reported for the New York Stock ExchangeComposite Transactions on that date or, if Stock is not traded on that date, on the next preceding date on which Stock was traded. |
(h) | Participant. The term Participant means any employee of an Employer who is eligible and elects to participate pursuant to the provisions of Section 2. |
(i) | Related Companies. The term Related Company means any company during any period in which it is a subsidiary corporation (as that term is defined in Code section 424(f)) with respect to the Company. |
A-6 Chubb Limited 2017 Proxy Statement
Superior Craftsmanship |
Chubb is defined by superior underwriting, service and execution. What those attributes say to us is superior craftsmanship. As craftspeople, we conceive, craft and deliver extraordinary insurance coverage and service that our customers deserve. |
Annual Meeting Proxy Card
|
IF YOU DO NOT WISH TO VOTE VIA THE INTERNET, FOLD ALONG THE PERFORATION, DETACH AND RETURN THE BOTTOM PORTION IN THE ENCLOSED ENVELOPE.
CHUBB LIMITED THIS PROXY IS SOLICITED ON BEHALF OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
The undersigned hereby appoints Homburger AG as independent proxy, and hereby authorizes it to represent and to vote, as directed below, all the Common Shares of Chubb Limited that the undersigned is entitled to vote at the Annual General Meeting to be held at 2:45 p.m. Central European Time on May 18, 2017 at the Companys offices at Bärengasse 32, CH-8001 Zurich, Switzerland. This proxy, when properly executed, will be voted as the undersigned directs herein. |
If no specific instructions are given herein, the undersigned hereby instructs the independent proxy to vote FOR each of Agenda Items 1-11 (including each subpart thereof) and for 1 YEAR on Agenda Item 12. If a new agenda item or a new proposal for an existing agenda item is put before the Annual General Meeting and no specific instructions are given herein, the undersigned hereby instructs the independent proxy to vote in accordance with the position of the Board of Directors. In order to assure that your votes are tabulated in time to be voted at the Annual General Meeting, you must submit your proxy card so that it is received by 6:00 p.m. Central European Time (12:00 noon Eastern Standard Time) on May 17, 2017.
A | Proposals The Board of Directors of the Company recommends that you vote your shares FOR each of Agenda Items 1-11 (including each subpart thereof) and for 1 YEAR on Agenda Item 12. | |
For | Against | Abstain | For | Against | Abstain | |||||||||
1. Approval of the management report, standalone financial statements and consolidated financial statements of Chubb Limited for the year ended December 31, 2016
2. Allocation of disposable profit and distribution of a dividend from reserves
2.1 Allocation of disposable profit
2.2 Distribution of a dividend out of legal reserves (by way of release and allocation to a dividend reserve) |
☐
☐
☐
|
☐
☐
☐
|
☐
☐
☐
|
3. Discharge of the Board of Directors
4. Election of Auditors
4.1 Election of PricewaterhouseCoopers AG (Zurich) as our statutory auditor
4.2 Ratification of appointment of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (United States) as independent registered public accounting firm for purposes of U.S. securities law reporting
4.3 Election of BDO AG (Zurich) as special audit firm |
☐
☐
☐
☐ |
☐
☐
☐
☐ |
☐
☐
☐
☐ | |||||||
5. Election of the Board of Directors |
For | Against | Abstain | For | Against | Abstain | For | Against | Abstain | For | Against | Abstain | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
5.1 - | Evan G. Greenberg |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.2 - | Robert M. Hernandez |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.3 - | Michael G. Atieh |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.4 - | Sheila P. Burke | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||
5.5 - | James I. Cash |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.6 - | Mary Cirillo | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.7 - | Michael P. Connors |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.8 - | John A. Edwardson |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||
5.9 - | Leo F. Mullin | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.10 - | Kimberly A. Ross |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.11 - | Robert W. Scully |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.12 - | Eugene B. Shanks, Jr. |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||
5.13 - | Theodore E. Shasta |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.14 - | David H. Sidwell | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.15 - | Olivier Steimer |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 5.16 - | James M. Zimmerman | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||
For | Against | Abstain |
* Please see reverse side for additional proposals and required signature | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
6. Election of Evan G. Greenberg as Chairman of the Board of Directors |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
02JAXE |
IF YOU DO NOT WISH TO VOTE VIA THE INTERNET, FOLD ALONG THE PERFORATION, DETACH AND RETURN THE BOTTOM PORTION IN THE ENCLOSED ENVELOPE.
Proposals (continued from reverse side)
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
7. | Election of the Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
For | Against | Abstain | For | Against | Abstain | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
7.1 - | Michael P. Connors |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 7.2 - | Mary Cirillo |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
10. |
Approval of the maximum compensation of the Board of Directors and Executive Management
10.1 Compensation of the Board of Directors until the next annual general meeting
10.2 Compensation of Executive Management for the next calendar year |
For
☐
☐ |
Against
☐
☐ |
Abstain
☐
☐ | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
7.3 - | Robert M. Hernandez |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | 7.4 - | Robert W. Scully |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
7.5 - | James M. Zimmerman |
☐ | ☐ | ☐ | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
For | Against | Abstain | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
8. |
Election of Homburger AG as independent proxy |
☐ |
☐ |
☐ |
11. |
Advisory vote to approve executive compensation under U.S. securities law requirements |
☐ |
☐ |
☐ | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 Year |
2 Years | 3 Years | Abstain | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
9. |
Approval of Amended and Restated Chubb Limited Employee Stock Purchase Plan |
☐ |
☐ |
☐ |
12. |
Advisory vote on frequency of submission of the advisory vote to approve executive compensation under U.S. securities law requirements |
☐ |
☐ |
☐ |
☐ |
If a new agenda item or a new proposal for an existing agenda item is put before the meeting, I/we hereby authorize and instruct the independent proxy to vote as follows: |
In accordance with the position of the Board of Directors |
☐ |
Against new items and proposals |
☐ |
Abstain |
☐ |
B | Non-Voting Items |
Change of Address Please print your new address below. | Comments Please print your comments below. | Meeting Attendance | ||||||
Mark the box to the right if you plan to attend the Annual Meeting. |
☐ |
C | Authorized Signatures This section must be completed for your vote to be counted. Date and Sign Below |
Please sign exactly as name appears hereon. When shares are held by joint tenants, both should sign. When signing as attorney, executor, administrator, trustee or guardian, please give full title as such. If a corporation, please sign in full corporate name by President or other authorized officer. If a partnership or limited liability company, please sign in partnership or limited liability company name by authorized person.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy) Please print date below. | Signature 1 Please keep signature within the box. | Signature 2 Please keep signature within the box. | ||||||
/ / |